Ransom Riggs
Strange Geographies: My Town’s “Aborted Suburb”
by Ransom Riggs - January 1, 2008 - 7:25 AM

Some people are seduced by strange and exotic lands abroad, and though I admit a weakness for the faraway, I also seek out surreal — and often overlooked — landscapes close to home. While back home in Southwest Florida for the holidays, I rediscovered a few. (After you read about this one, we’d love it if you’d share some of your own!)

Rotonda Sands, the “Aborted Suburb”
rotunda.jpgI grew up in Southern Florida, the land of sleepy golf communities, condo developments and down-in-the-mouth pseudo-resorts. One of the best known such communities in my area was called “Rotonda,” the name-appropriateness of which becomes pretty obvious when the community is seen from the air (thanks, Google Maps). Founded in the 1960s, it’s about a mile in diameter and packed with golf courses and modest vacation homes — or at least, about 3/4 of its pie-shaped volume is. The other 1/4 pie-wedge never really came to fruition — despite, rumor has it, investments from such high-profilers as Ed McMahon and O.J. Simpson — and so for years the wedge, known as “Rotonda Sands,” sat undeveloped and largely untrammeled, even though overeager planners had gridded it with streets, cul-de-sacs, fire hydrants and even street signs; all the trappings of suburbia, with none of the houses.

culdesac.jpg

Needless to say, by the time my friends and I had discovered this desolate locale some 30 years later, its streets now cracked, signage faded and lots wildly overgrown by aggressive Floridian undergrowth, it had become a surreal place indeed. Evidence of old campfires and piles of garbage made it clear that the only visitors to these empty cul-de-sacs (pictured) were drifters and teenagers looking for a good time away from prying eyes. (Also, drug planes had used its long streets as landing strips back in the 70s and 80s, though we never found any bricks of heroin among the weeds.)

My friends and I graduated and left town, and until last week, it had been years since I paid a visit to our local wasteland. Curious to see if the mid-2000s Florida housing boom had done anything to change Rotonda Sands’ state of perpetual purgatory, I drove down the other day. To my great surprise, what had been an empty grid for nearly 30 years was suddenly pocked with houses! But as I drove around, wondering who in their right minds would want to live way out in this peculiar boondock, it slowly dawned on me that, for the most part, the answer was nobody. The houses were either empty or, in most cases, unfinished — the hurricanes of 2004 and the decline in the housing market had dealt a one-two punch to the whole area, knocking Rotunda Sands back into the stone age just as it was getting to its feet.

chopin.jpg

If anything, the new ruins which now populate the Sands make it an even stranger and sadder place; it now has the feeling of a kind of architectural mausoleum or a bombed-out city, with the few people who actually finished their houses and moved in before the crash acting as its lonely caretakers — whereas before it had just been evidence of best-laid plans that never came to fruition. I’m told that the area has become a magnet for thieves; the air conditioning units and copper wiring left in the unfinished homes tend to disappear, eventually finding their way to the resale market.

forsale.jpg

More photos: it doesn’t take long for nature to start reclaiming its territory.

weeds.jpg

Most of the houses are identical in design; their only differences are the degree to which they’re unfinished.

sky.jpg

rightface.jpg

The lizard loves his new house.

lizard.jpg

This blank billboard on the outskirts of Rotonda Sands kinda sums it up. (For sale: nothing!)

bigsign.jpg

December 2011 Update!
Rotonda Sands is beginning to look like a normal, if somewhat sparsely built-out, housing development. They’ve replaced all the fading signs with brand new ones, finished building nearly all the half-built houses, and there are cars in driveways and kids riding their bikes around, and some new hiking trails nearby. Not such a Strange Geography anymore, as it turns out. So think of the above as a snapshot from history, not something you can expect to find if you visit Rotonda today.

You can check out more Strange Geographies columns here.

Click here to get a Risk-Free issue of mental_floss magazine
Comments (59)
  1. I live in Ukraine and we see that kind of thing all the time here- but I had no idea you could find flocks of half-finished homes like that back home in the States… and the stealing and re-selling of copper wiring and a/c units- well that sounds like the former USSR, too. bizarre

  2. My parents live in a suburb in central Florida that reminds me of this. It was in the process of being built when the housing market crashed, so it isn’t yet old enough to have the decaying shells of houses. It does have the fully completed streets that lead the nowhere, complete with cul-de-sacs consisting of nothing but empty lots. Always kind of spooky to walk through the neighborhood.

  3. That picture with the lizard explains it. Those houses are too small! You could barely get your fist through a window!

  4. In the 70s, the company with its high-pressure salespeople in Las Vegas was selling lots in Rotonda (and yes, the movie we watched was narrated by Ed McMahon). As soon as you made it through the presentation, you were immediately bombarded with the paperwork to sign for your choice of a lot on a golf course or on the marina (for your boat). If you managed to walk away from this harassment, you were given two free tickets to any show on the Strip. My husband and I went twice, a year apart, and were able to see some pretty great shows.

    I always wondered what happened to the property and now I know.

  5. It’s so eerie – like looking at pictures of Prypiat, Ukraine or Centralia, Pennsylvania.

  6. Thanks for the pictures! This reminds me of abandonedbutnotforgotten.com … you should submit your pictures there.

  7. My wife’s grandparents live in Sunny Hills, FL.

    it’s probably about 60 square miles of exactly what you describe. very eerie the few times we’ve driven up there.

    if you google map for “Sunny Hills, Florida”, look to the south and southeast of where it puts you and you’ll see nothng but empty streets.

  8. Hey! I was just visiting my dad in Englewood, FL and got lost in the Rotonda area! My husband and I were going “exploring” to find new restaurants and instead ended up going round and round and round. We didn’t find any restaurants, needless to say.

    Patti S.
    Ann Arbor, MI

  9. Wow, if I lived there, I would be over to that area all the time, doing who knows what and filming amateur action movies and things like that.

  10. I worked in the area for 25 yrs and Rotonda has grown up to be a large community.If you look at it from the air it’s pie shape,every pie section has street after street of homes and golf courses. In each golf course you find restaurents. All along the out side of the pie and each section are cannels full of fish, the Gulf of Mexico is just 5 minutes away.
    Rotonda was the home of the Super Star TV show also.
    Realy not a bad place, just affected by the housing slump

  11. My aunt lives in one of the other pie segments, so I’ve seen this area, but not since prior to 2004. It’s a shame that some potentially really nice homes have been abandoned there.

  12. I live in Florida, too (a little further up the west coast) and could probably show you half a dozen sites just like this — all of them within a 15 min. drive from my house. Hideous scars carved into once-beautiful pastures, full of streets that go nowhere, fronted by crumbling concrete facades studded with faded signs promising Paradise. It truly is beginning to look Third-worldish.
    Thanks for the great post!

  13. What you have described is the result of the Mackle Brothers, who brought us Deltona, Rotunda, Spring Hill and others.
    There are several 1960′s subdivisions that were built up in my area, Sebring, FL when I was a child. Whenever I go to these areas, it always strikes me as deja vu all over again. Spring Hill has street names that echo the other subs, like Deltona Blvd, or Linden Drive.

  14. Reminds me of the ghost resort town around the Salton Sea in Southern California.

  15. “Pockafwye Says:
    January 2nd, 2008 at 3:13 pm
    Reminds me of the ghost resort town around the Salton Sea in Southern California.”

    That is exactly what I was going to say! I grew up in San Diego and took road trips across the desert many times. Ghost towns can be found all over the deserts in Southern California containing dilapidated trailers with dusty old rusted out cars piled around sitting in the middle of nowhere.

  16. It kinda looks beautiful, in its own fashion.

    I think we need more waste lands like this, monuments to our insanity.

  17. What do you expect from a bunch of spam-suckin yahoos who couldn’t figure out a butterfly ballot and elected anyone named Jeb to governor…let alone anyone named Jeb Bush. I say let the lizards have the place…and set up a big fence to keep ‘em out of the Northwest.

  18. I grew up in Englewood, Fl and surprisingly some of my friends families still live in Rotonda. I went to LBHS there and it was a fantastic place to grow up- except for the fact that I was on the island. Most kids had nothing better to do than to smoke weed and start fires and get into all kinds of mischief. Hell, drug running I think used to be an olympic sport out there.

    The town never really had anything going for it. Only when I was in middle school or high school did a Walmart first appear. While they usually bring in a lower class in high population areas, it was amazing to have a store opened later to get anything you needed. The first of its kind in this town.

    I went down there for a friends wedding a year or so ago. I’m delighted to see Mama’s Pizza is still there. Vinnie is amazing to take on the place after his dad died.

    You’d think someplace on the coast would revive itself but there’s really nothing else around. Barely any restaurants that are any good, a few bars, no entertainment. The nearest movie theater is probably 30 mins away at least. It’s hard to bring any of that in because a lot of the residents are snowbirds too and in the summer you’d be hurting for business.

    Englewood, she just ain’t what she used to be.

  19. I live in West Palm Beach–where is the Rotunda? I’ve seen this every now and then, and in a lot of the newest communities in this area, at least 25% are empty.

    Heath

  20. Wow. It’s funny how you’re talking about where I’m currently /growing/ up. xD
    I live in Port Charlotte, and my mother (and myself) hate driving through Rotonada.
    It’s great to see people from these parts can grow up to do something with their lives.

    (I’m actually on a computer at LBHS, atm)

  21. All of you are missing the point , Rotonda is not a “ghost town” google map it and look at a satellite pic of the area it is hugh.Ten’s of thousands of poeple live there. The area where Ransom is talking about Rotonda Sands is in the far lower right side and yes not very many poeple live there it was one of the last areas to be developed.
    I know I was a firefighter for that area for 25 yrs and watched grow.

  22. This is going to sound bizarre, but there is another aborted ‘rotunda’ style suburb that was proposed 80 years ago and never completed.

    I was perusing the area behind Hume, in Canberra (Australia’s capital) in google maps and found map information for a suburb which literally isn’t there.

    It’s called Environa and was planned to be a rich suburb until the Great Depression came about. It’s built around a ‘rotunda’ style and there is currently only one residency there, in the centre of the rotunda.

    Contact me for more information including the original map proposal and history.
    You can find the map and satellite imagery on Google Maps – search ‘Environa’ – there’s only one.

  23. We vacation at Palm Island, just across the intercoastal waterway by Johnny Leverock’s. I always see this on Google Earth and imagined this totally amazing area with golf courses and everything. So much for that!

  24. I used to be a homeless rodeo clown but now i am a world class magician !

  25. (Not Finished typing…)

    GDC is who Built Rotunda {yes, the Mackle bros.}

    Not far from Rotunda is a Part of North Port that is similar, built by GDC

    And do a search on wikipedia for “The Compound ” another abandoned GDC plan in east FL.

  26. I’ve really gotten interested recently in partly developed plots in Google Maps — where on the Maps part you can see lots of streets, but in the satellite view you can see that its just graded dirt streets with few or no buildings. Rotunda is more developed than this (20 years ago it might have qualified), but two good examples from my area are Rio Rancho Estates and the desert southeast of Los Lunas, both in the greater Albuquerque area of New Mexico. (You can enter Rio Rancho Estates directly into Google Maps, but the latter you’ll have to enter Los Lunas and then pan southeast.) Rio Rancho Estates (as well as about half of Rio Rancho which is adjacent) is a vast area of streets with nothing else. The area is comparable to Albuquerque itself. I’m not sure when this street plan was made, but I think that whoever the developers are they still expect to fill all that in someday. I don’t know much about the area near Los Lunas except that you can see a large street structure (actually extending pretty far south) in the satellite view.

    I’ve started to collect these, and another great example (albeit with some houses here and there) is Salton City in California. If anyone knows of others, please email me at jaybrotz@yahoo.com.

  27. During a google search on “strange Los Angeles homes”, I somehow landed on your blog about Rotunda. It’s funny… a few years back when I lived in Miami, bad weather diverted my return flight to fly over the Gulf coast for a safer landing. We were flying beneath the clouds when I saw this wagon wheel formation on the earth below. It entranced me and I studied it’s form until it escaped my view.

    When I got home I scanned the satellite maps to try and find it, but came up empty. Now I’ve found it!

    But what’s even WEIRDER is discovering the name of this place. When I was around age four or five, during the early 70s, my parents almost bought property in a place called Rotunda. I was very little, but I remember it because the sales rep took us up into a small airplane and we flew over it. It was in the very early stages of development at that time. I remember seeing all the water … the gulf, the bay, the channels. I can’t remember why my parents never ended up buying, but it’s probably a good thing they didn’t!

  28. That was a very interesting story. The pictures marched in time to the beat and that made it fun to read all the way through. Thanks for sharing :)

  29. If I may, I found another abandoned development. Well, they have streetlights, utilities, and streets, but no houses. It’s not profound because the trees block the view, but you can see the “price reduced” signs. The link is to an article I wrote on my new blog.

    (Sorry if this is against the rules, I just thought it was cool. I’m also a long time commenter and feed subscriber, so it’s not like I’m spamming. Remove if you want.)

  30. This is a really good article and so informative. I Googled Rotunda to check it out b/c my father just put an offer down for a house there. Now, I’m scared. I hope and pray he changes his mind!

  31. Rotunda is like deja vu. 20 years ago
    my parents had a wonderful place in Port
    Lucaya in Freeport, Bahamas. I would
    typically go down once or twice a year to dive and gamble. On one of the rainy
    days, I decided to do a little exploration of our island paradise and
    discovered an uninhabited subdivision
    with paved streets to nowhere, man-made
    canals and even an abandoned low-rise
    hotel…it seemed a perfect place to
    stage a nether-world “Waiting for Godot”
    or “Krapp’s Last Tape”. Now I don’t
    even need a passport to discover man’s last refuge from himself.

  32. I used to live in Lancaster, California in the 1990 and 1991. There were several developments like that in Lancaster and Palmdale (5 miles to the south) that were abandoned. One became famous in the movies. Lethal Weapon 3 (Mel Gibson & Danny Glover) burned down one such development in the movie. This was an actual housing development that had gone belly-up and sold out to the production company to be used in the movie.

  33. The post WWI Florida Land Boom collapse in the mid twenties was brought about by a series of disasters from which the ’29 crash made recovery impossible. After WWII, there were still large abandoned areas of street grids, sidewalks, fire hydrants and streetlights. They existed as communities on the maps, but only snakes, weeds and lizards resided at their addresses.

  34. My brother and his wife have lived in Florida for about 10 years now. When I turned 16, I came down to visit them and they took me to one of these abandoned neigborhoods and taught me how to drive! It was perfect. Clear roads, roadsigns, and no one (and nothing) that I could hit. Very cool.

  35. I used to live in the California high desert. A town had been developed there that had alot of the streets placed and named, but with little developement. Known as ‘California City’ it still seems as though there is still plenty of room to grow.

  36. @Peter “Monuments to our insanity” I LOL’d!

    Another Florida ghost town I’ve heard about is Rosewood. Supposedly it was an all-black township supported by a grain mill until one of its residents was accused of raping the (white) sheriff’s daughter. A mob descended on the town, massacred the residents, and set most of the town on fire. That’s what I’ve heard, anyway. Google Maps shows Rosewood as a series of empty lots and streets.

  37. Isn’t Rotonda’s biggest claim to fame the fact that when it was first being developed, back in the 1970s, it was the site of ABC-TV’s “Superstars” competitions?

    And which is the correct spelling? Rotonda or Rotunda?

    -”BB”-

  38. This was a very interesting article, but I’m afraid when you look at this neighbourhood on google maps / street view, it’s the antithesis of “abandoned”. A portion in the lower 1/4 appears to be a bit run down, but I would hardly describe it as deserted. However, if you happen to be looking at it on google maps, zoom out a bit and see the sattelite view which exposes TENS of miles of grid-patterned streets in the surrounding areas which feature only 1 or 2 (sometimes run down) homes each – just crazy.

  39. I find these places fascinating as well. We had an abandon half built mansion in east Honolulu (Henry J Kaiser of Kaiser Permente died during the construction) It takes up acres of prime Hawaii real estate on a bay. Has three seperate units, including a cafeteria. The most surreal part is the 60s technological equipment throughout the house. If you ever make it to Hawaii, check it out.

  40. Try the entire city of Detroit. It’s gradually reverting to prairie.

  41. I flew over this on approach to Fort Lauderdale International last fall and looked down at this subdivision in awe. But like the girl I was flying south to meet — Rotunda looks much better from a distance. Get close and the cracks begin to show.

  42. In a town called Tallahassee FL there is an old abandoned Tuberculosis Hospital that was also used as an institution for retarded children for awhile that is called Sunland Hospital but the locals call it Sunnyland. It has been pretty much torn apart by destructive teens but it is still plenty creepy to go through from what I hear. I don’t know the name of the road it’s on but I do know it is on the same road as the Florida Dept of Law Enforcement which you would think would deter the kids but not so much ;)

  43. There is a town called Centralia, PA that is an old mining town that was abandoned by its people due to a massive underground fire. I came across its history in a book, and did some more research online. Basically, a fire caught in the town’s mine (the fire’s origins are unknown) and efforts to put it out have failed since 1962! The ground is supposedly warm to the touch and there are pictures of steam coming from the surface. It’s certainly surreal…

  44. i’m wondering what the story is on why they built an incomplete wheel. why not finish the circle?

    thoughts?

  45. Ha come to Rotonda today. 3/4th of the community is a pretty standard golf boating area. Yes the developers have gone but people still live comfortably in the finished areas enjoying the weather, water and golf. On second thought don’t come it’s relatively quiet for a coastal area with great beaches. I hope it stays that way for my life time.

  46. the theft of wiring ,copper,and anything else deemed of value from abandoned buildings or otherwise(really,you needed to steal the ac from a church?!?!)has been an increasing problem in urban areas since the 80′s driven by the crack epidemic and now most likely fueled by meth wth happened to us america

  47. I am an italian student of architecture, I have to find out a program for a design project there in Rotonda, it is an exercise. Any suggestions?

  48. spelled Rotonda West.
    A great place to live, especially if retired and a golfer/boater/beach bum type of a person. last section was shut down to development by the environmentalists. Too bad, would have been a good area for more people to enjoy Florida living.
    The surrounding areas outside the “circle” are sparsely populated.

  49. My parents live in Rotonda. Their home is beautiful, their neighbors are great and the subdivision is awesome. I look forward to living there one day.

  50. I love Rotona great place to bike, fish, and golf and beaching

    good neighbors what more can I ask

  51. if you are trying to find places , and houses like you show here tere are everywhere!!! starting in NY and Chicago
    to LA . Why not to look for something nice?
    My husband and I, we bought hause in Rotonda West in June. We went there 3x since then. Nice,warm and relaxing place , beautifull beach.We are very happy with our decision !

  52. Originally the plan was to give everyone in Rotonda access to the intercoastal waterway via the system of canals. But the environmental protection agency prohibited that to prevent salt water incursion into fresh water areas. So the unfinished south western section was turned into a wildlife preserve and the canals were never connected to the intercoastal. There are some very modest homes in Rotonda and some very fancy places. It is no longer the ghost town as has been portrayed. And I believe the radius of the circle is one mile, the diameter 2 miles. That is, from the perimeter circle to the center is one mile. It’s a huge place.

  53. I have made Rotonda West home for most of the last three years. While many areas of the development are exactly as pictured and described, most of the neighborhoods within the circle proper are proper homes, with yards, landscaping, holiday decorations seasonally, and all the trappings of comfortable Florida retirement living. Other developments to the east and south (one of which is actually named Rotonda Sands) haven’t had the benefit of owners who could and did finish their homes. The photos are a partial “snapshot” at best, and a misguided portrayal of the truth at worst. Rotonda West is a quiet, serene, calm retirement area. There are plenty of homes at bargain prices, making Florida affordable. Research it for yourself, there are many real estate offices who would love to hear from investors and potential homeowners.

  54. It’s a great place, the sky is blue. it’s great to bike, fish, and golf and beaching.

    BTW: good neighbors!

  55. two things

    1) the plural of cul-de-sac is “culs-de-sac”, sorry the geek in me just couldn’t let it slide; and

    2) THis seems like the type of spot that would have been a prime location for drug and alcohol riddled high school parties. any signs of that out there?

  56. Wow – blast from the past! When I was a kid my parents came very close to buying a vacation home in Rotonda in the early ’70s. I’d forgotten all about it until I came across your blog. I remember going with them to the presentation featuring Ed McMahon. They debated the purchase for a long time (trusty Mr. McMahon was convincing) but eventually decided against it for some reason (good thing…with their luck they probably would have bought in the Sands).

    Terrific blog, by the way!

  57. I find it hard to believe the general thought here….We have always valued space around our dwelling…good for nature,spirit and peace of mind…The sands are an ideal part of an otherwise perfect community ,with great homesites ….

    In its present state,(witch I hope the secret does not get out)life is plenty peaceful and private.,,and beautifully kept up with small lakes and streams..This is what this soon to be gated community enjoys…The proximity to the golf courses ,beach ,marinas ,restaurants,shopping and close by businesses,are ideal…(golfcartable!)The sands will fill up soon enough,but I hope the next 20 years for it to remain as is…I really like it…but I know that the area will soon be rediscovered and fill..sigh..
    This blogger is young ,shortsighted,and belongs in a metro -city…I wonder has he had any neighbors??To be tightly pact into suberbia is a sentence sometimes,..The wheel is full of houses…the sand are just outside the wheel! dugh!good grief..There are plenty of (neighbors) yards away,if you want them that is..sheesh!

    we own two lots and are building soon

    Please ! keep up the good work!

    shelly

  58. Hey, Ransom here — been four years or so since I wrote this. A response to a few of the comments above:

    I do think I represent Rotonda accurately: it’s 3/4 golf courses and vacation homes, absolutely normal for SW Florida. The “sands” quarter of the wagon wheel is odd and interesting not because it’s wilderness, but because it is wilderness that has/is reclaiming what was laid out to be a planned community, with streets and signs and water mains and fire hydrants, and a few houses, too. I can see how living out there would appeal to people who like their space — I like my space, too. I don’t think Rotondans should be embarrassed about the Sands. But they shouldn’t be surprised if its of interest to people looking for unusual landscapes; it has a touch of the post-apocalyptic about it. That’s why I like it. I make a point of going down there every time I’m home, just to see if any new houses have been built, and how much the scrub is encroaching onto the old fading street grid.

    Thanks to those who’ve posted additional info. Fascinating!

  59. Mr.riggs…Your article on the sands,keeps folks away,….thats good for me.Although…others who would LIKE more neighbors might not agree on the smear of the (post-apocalyptic,aborted suburb) label…fact is ,if this were a suburb of any of the big cities..(witch it is not)these lots all,would have houses on them.The utilities ,lakes,and roads alone would be sufficient to draw contracters and home owners.

    proximity to the ocean and beaches for retirees and families,is what the sands offers(at a good price)and THAT is what will be in demand on the golf coast looking to the future..

    sure…what you now see as unfinished,and deserted..will soon be full ,as the hoards of baby boomer northerners seek to escape,winter and the high utility bills.

    Like I said..you seem sort of young,and perhaps play too many of those post apocalyptic,video games…sorry

    The sands has tons going for it,and the golden rule of real estate has always been, LOCATION! LOCATION! LOCATION!…thats all

    thanks for the pics,anyhow..how about some showing the other side of a sands investment???

    not a realtor,
    shelly

Comment

commenting policy