mental_floss magazine
SUBSCRIBE >
GIFT SUBSCRIPTIONS >
DIGITAL SUBSCRIPTIONS >
subscriber services >

This weekend, you’ll be hearing a lot about a tiny, out-of-the-way place that normally has to get hit by a natural disaster to get our attention. Such is the wonder and magic of primary season.
I’m not talking about some quiet town in the middle of Tornado Alley, though. On June 1, all eyes are on Puerto Rico, the small Caribbean island that will send 63 delegates to the Democratic National Convention, even though its residents don’t get to vote in the general election.
In November’s general election, only residents of the 50 states (and, since the 23rd amendment, the District of Columbia) get to vote. The primaries, however, are run by state and local governments, and caucuses are run privately by political parties. Since Puerto Rico has a local government and political parties, both events are fair game, and residents of Puerto Rico participate in the nominating process of both major parties and send delegates to each party’s national convention. Other organized territories like Guam and the U.S. Virgin Islands do the same.
What else do Puerto Ricans get to do? Here’s a quick history lesson.
All the land that is part of the U.S. but isn’t part of a state, the District of Columbia or assigned to a Native Nation has historically been designated as a territory. The modern generic term for these regions is insular area (which is also applied to freely associated states), since territory is now more narrowly defined by the federal government as an insular area under the jurisdiction of the United States. These territories can be…
• incorporated (under the jurisdiction of the United States, over which Congress has determined that the United States Constitution is to be applied to the local governments and residents in the same way it is applied to those of the states)…
…or…
• unincorporated (under U.S. jurisdiction, over which Congress has determined that only select parts of the U.S. Constitution apply)…
…and may also be…
• organized (where Congress has explicitly granted self-government through an Organic Act, which normally includes provisions for the establishment of a Bill of Rights for the territory and the framework of a three-branched government)…
…or…
• unorganized (without direct authorization of self-government)…
…and all of them can put “Made in the U.S.A.” on their products.
Today, the U.S. has only one incorporated territory—the Palmyra Atoll, which is owned by The Nature Conservancy and managed by the Department of the Interior. Among our numerous unincorporated territories, Puerto Rico and the Northern Mariana Islands hold the status of “commonwealth.”* This means “a self-governing, autonomous political unit voluntarily associated with the United States”). This term doesn’t seem to have any significance beyond labeling them as one type of unincorporated, organized territory and is mainly a matter of politics. It comes from the English translation of Puerto Rico’s official name (Commonwealth of Puerto Rico). A literal translation of its name in Spanish, “Estado Libre Asociado de Puerto Rico” would have been “Associated Free State of Puerto Rico,” and since it actually isn’t in a Compact of Free Association with the U.S., “Commonwealth” was substituted.
So what does all that mean for Puerto Rico? Well, among other things…
• Puerto Ricans are statutory U.S. citizens. They’re eligible for Social Security benefits, can receive federal welfare and serve in the armed forces.
• Most sections of the Internal Revenue Code don’t apply there. Residents don’t pay federal income taxes unless they do business with the federal government or run a business that sends funds to the U.S.. All residents do, however, pay other federal taxes like payroll taxes (social security and Medicare) and import/export taxes.
• United States federal law is applicable to Puerto Rico.
• They are not represented by a U.S. Representative or Senator, but by a Resident Commissioner in the U.S. House of Representatives who has the right of voice and can vote in the Committee of the Whole, but does not have a full House Vote.
• Puerto Ricans residing in the United States have all the rights and privileges associated with residing in a state.
*To anyone living in the Commonwealths of Virginia, Kentucky, Massachusetts or Pennsylvania who might be concerned about territorial status and voting eligibility: Don’t worry. You live in a regular State that simply decided to refer to itself as a commonwealth a long time ago as a matter of political theory. The Kentucky state government’s website, for example, says that at the time Kentucky was petitioning for statehood, the term meant that “all power was vested in and derived from an equally free and independent people rather than a hierarchical and/or feudal system under a king.” It was a way of saying that the people were running the government, and not the other way around.
You forgot to mention that Puerto Ricans were able to vote on what Puerto Rico is. They had the option of becoming a state in the US, becoming their own country or stay in their current position.
They voted for the latter.
posted by Mark on 5-30-2008 at 10:00 pm
Why Does Puerto Rico Get A Primary? | politikly.com…
\r\nThis weekend, youll be hearing a lot about a tiny, out-of-the-way place that normally has to get…
posted by politikly.com | politics and world news on 6-1-2008 at 3:21 am
Why would they ever choose to be a state? In other words, why buy the cow when you can get the milk from other hardworking American taxpayers?
posted by Justin on 6-2-2008 at 5:29 am
im so tired of hearing about the hardworking american taxpayers. shut up. your not the only ones who work hard. puerto rico is one of the poorest places owned by america but we offer them NO help. what about my hard earned tax money paying for your 15 toothless kids. i dont have any kids but i gotta pay for your retards to go to school. so shut up.
posted by mark on 6-2-2008 at 11:18 am
Mark’s edited version (still needs some revising). This is mental_floss.com, not dental_floss.com, so before you start judging Justin’s kids’ oral health, please reread and proof your diatribes.
I’m so tired of hearing about the hardworking American taxpayers. Shut up! You’re not the only one who works hard. Puerto Rico is one of the poorest places owned by America, but we offer them NO help. What about my hard-earned tax money paying for your 15 toothless kids? I don’t have any kids, but I have to pay for your retards to go to school, so shut up.
posted by Wendy on 6-2-2008 at 10:43 pm
@Mark - PR has has several votes in the last 10 years about statehood, independence, or commonwealth. The outcome has always been for commonwealth, but with every vote, there are more for Statehood.
BTW, PR will never become a state because of politics. The population is about 3.5 million which would give PR a lot of power in Presidential elections. Having spoken to a senator once about the issue about 10 years ago this is what he told me. He didn’t know I was Puerto Rican.
@Justin - PR’s would want statehood so they can have the privilege of voting for President. Plus it would bring more benefits of cleaning up the island.
@Mark - Puerto Rico does get help from the Federal Government in times of natural disasters, and other events.
As a Puerto Rican living in the US, I have always been livid that Puerto Rican’s on the island can’t vote for President.
posted by Patricia on 6-3-2008 at 9:09 am