Last night’s LOST season finale made mention of a “Dead Man’s Trigger,” which is another term for a Dead Man’s Switch. Although these devices are well known to some geeks, I thought I’d write a little explainer to introduce the notion more broadly. (Warning: very minor LOST spoilers follow.) While the LOST switch was in fact a “fail-deadly” (the opposite of a fail-safe), the concept is similar. In fact, this isn’t the first time we’ve seen a Dead Man’s Switch on LOST: Season 2 was all about Desmond’s switch.
The Dead Man’s Switch is generally a fail-safe device intended to take action if a human fails to routinely activate it — in other words, if the human dies, the switch goes off, and something happens.
Historically, a Dead Man’s Switch was installed in potentially dangerous machinery like locomotives, streetcars, and subways. The switch itself could take many forms, though typically it was a handle of some sort that needed to be operated by the user. By forcing the human operator of these machines to occasionally (or even continuously) activate the switch, you could (theoretically) ensure that the machine would shut down if the operator was dead, incapacitated, or missing. Common mechanical Dead Man’s Switches exist in New York subways and even lawnmowers and tractors. Here’s a snippet from Wikipedia:
In many modern New York Subway trains, for example, the dead man’s switch is incorporated into the train’s speed control. On the R142A the train operator must continually hold the lever in place. This was depicted in the movie and book The Taking of Pelham 123, in which a group of men hijack a New York City subway train for ransom, but because of the Dead-man’s feature, cannot escape while the train is moving.
Every lawn mower sold in the US since 1982 has an “operator-presence” device, which by law must stop the blades within 3 seconds after the user lets go of the controls.
Many modern systems could benefit from a Dead Man’s Switch. For example, typical automative Cruise Control systems don’t have such a switch, which could allow a vehicle to effectively drive itself after the user falls asleep. Of course, this doesn’t last long, as the vehicle hits something sooner or later — but wouldn’t a better failure mode be to slow down rather than keep going?
In high tech, ubergeeks have been using Dead Man’s Switches to protect their data or implement disaster-containment protocols in case something goes terribly wrong. If you’re a political dissident or involved in something else potentially dicey, a Dead Man’s Switch can be implemented as software, a sort of “nuclear option” that will zap your data — or contact trusted compatriots — if you fail to activate it. Slashdot held a discussion entitled What Does Your Dead Man’s Switch Do? in 2007, leading to several interesting stories (and tons of off-topic discussion). Here’s a good example:
I often take part in political protests, and have on occasion been arrested and held for days.
So, I put together a quick routine using perl and chron that dispatches email to my workplace, the local legal rep contact, and some friends. The later includes directions to a hidden key and asks them to feed my cat until they hear from me. I only enable the system when I’m expecting a significant risk of arrest. Once it’s started, if I don’t either log into the machine or send myself an email containing a specific string once every 24 hours, the alarm goes off.
The Dead Man’s Switch has also appeared in literature; one popular example I can recall is the nuclear trigger on Raven’s motorcycle in Neal Stephenson’s Snow Crash. But I’m sure there are more examples out there. Have you come across a Dead Man’s Switch, in life or in fiction? Share in the comments!
I have one on the forklift I operate at work. It’s called a stand up forklift. There is no seat; hence the name. Anyway, it will only run if you are standing on the pedal. Take your foot off the pedal and it stops. This is a safety feature incorperated in case you somehow get thrown or knocked off the machine. It stops on a dime if that happens. Not very interesting but just wanted to share.
posted by mike on 5-30-2008 at 2:19 pm
Jetskis and treadmills are equipped with a similar kill switch device which the user wears attached to the wrist.
Falling off pulls the key and stops the machine.
posted by Aye Chihuahua on 5-30-2008 at 5:02 pm
If you’ve ever had a fluoroscopic study in a diagnostic imaging facility, the foot pedal that the radiologist steps on is a Dead Man’s Switch. It is designed to immediately stop the radiation should the doctor remove their foot for any reason.
posted by john on 5-30-2008 at 5:51 pm
I used to be an airline fueler, and the Dead Man Switch is this oval/rectangular piece with a handle inside, and controls the air pressure to deliver the JP-4. If you overfill a plane with fuel, it’s not pretty, so the switch is obviously useful. Still, some lazy fuelers would wedge a rag in it, and when caught were summarily fired.
posted by Johnny Cat on 5-30-2008 at 8:58 pm
I operated one of those stand up lifts 20 years ago Mike. If you let off the pedal and weren’t expecting it, your solar plexus was right in the “necking knob” on the forklift steering wheel. It stopped in a hurry if you got off that pedal.
posted by Dave L on 5-30-2008 at 11:24 pm
Dr. Strangelove! I kept expecting this to come up in the article.
posted by shawn on 5-31-2008 at 10:57 am
A really redonkulous Matthew Reilly book called “Area 7″ revolves around a dead man’s switch having been installed directly onto the President’s heart. So if he dies, bombs go off. It is, of course, our hero’s job to make sure that doesn’t happen.
posted by Christina on 5-31-2008 at 2:58 pm
In Orson Scott Card’s novel “Shadow of the Hegemon” (part of the Ender’s Game series) uses a dead man’s switch in the form of an email. One character knows something about another character’s health, but isn’t ready to tell him yet, so she sets up an email to be sent out every 24 hours unless she stops it so if she dies unexpectedly, the second character will know the information.
posted by Kimberly on 5-31-2008 at 3:59 pm
movie; safe house/patrick stewart
x spook, his mind is degrading due to alheimers.
posted by kikz on 6-1-2008 at 12:23 pm
sorry… sticky z on my keyboard….
posted by kikz on 6-1-2008 at 12:24 pm
An improvised dead-man switch attached to a nuclear warhead figures in Robert Heinlein’s classic short, ‘The Long Watch.’
posted by RNB on 6-2-2008 at 6:31 am
I’ve read that suicide bombers often employ something like this. Once the bomb is armed they hold a button in or something like that. They release the trigger/button/whatever when they are ready for their 72 virgins. But if the police or whoever shoots them, the bomb still goes off.
posted by Andrew D on 6-4-2008 at 2:39 pm