mental_floss magazine
SUBSCRIBE >
GIFT SUBSCRIPTIONS >
DIGITAL SUBSCRIPTIONS >
subscriber services >
According to The Buffalo News, John Edwards and Karl Rove are slated to debate at the University of Buffalo on September 26. And while much has been said about Edwards’ ability as a trial lawyer and the millions he’s racked up, not enough has been said about Karl Rove’s skill as a high school debater. Here’s journalist Wayne Slater in a PBS interview on one of Rove’s tactics, used to intimidate 9th grade competition.
“Karl Rove was not only the best debater in Olympus High School, but also one of the best debaters in Utah when he was in high school. He went to a lot of competitions with other schools. One of the things he was good at was talking off the cuff and developing enormously skilled responses to the other guys, something we see even these days.
The other thing he understood, though, was you intimidate the person from the beginning. What can you do to scare your opponent before the debate even comes across? Now, in those days, what students did was bring in a shoebox or a small box full of debate cards, and these were cards that basically said what your position was so that you would refer to those during the course of the debate.
The other side would have a box. So he’d bring in two. The other side might have two. And over time, he’d bring in four. Ultimately he and his colleague would bring in on a dolly, on a hand cart, a giant box of thousands and thousands of debate cards as if to scare and intimidate the other side, thinking, my gosh, this is a debater of enormous reputation, a debater who is obviously well prepared and better prepared than I am. Rove would put these boxes in front of him on the desk and then start out on the debate. Well, [what] nobody knew until years later was that almost all of these cards were blank. It was a show of intimidation, and Rove usually won.”
I really hope he recycles the strategy, and shows up to the event Imelda Marcos-style. Of course, the other story I just find hilarious is Rove’s high school campaign to become President of his Student Senate. Whether you like Rove or not, you have to admit the gimmick was genius. It’s the 4th question Slater answers here and definitely worth reading.
Comments (8)
Comment
MC ROVE!
posted by Ira on 7-9-2008 at 3:13 pm
Why is Karl Rove debating anyone?? He’s not a politician, he’s a frequent “guest” on FixedNews.
- Jess
posted by Jess on 7-9-2008 at 3:23 pm
The Volkswagon convertible would also be a neat entrance trick. Maybe the convertible could pull the cart of cards, for double the intimidation. :)
@Jess
I was not aware that the right to debate was limited to “official” politicians. He is a figure of influence in his party, just as Edwards is in his. If your best reasoning for him not being able to take part in a debate is that he is a frequent guest on a cable channel that you do not happen to like, then you might want to do some brushing up before entering *your* next debate…because that’s not particularly logically sound. Anyway, even if he isn’t actively seeking office, he definitely fits the definition of a politician (see your favorite dictionary for an explanation).
posted by kate on 7-9-2008 at 3:35 pm
I think he’s just someone that can draw a crowd. Particularly, with his and Edwards’ powers combined!
posted by Mangesh on 7-9-2008 at 3:35 pm
How is Rove going to debate when all he ever does is cower behind Executive Privelge whenever anyone asks him a question?
posted by Florida on 7-9-2008 at 3:38 pm
slater also co-authored a book with james moore which mentions rove’s debate career. an excerpt describing rove’s debate background with a little more detail is available on the edebate list-serv, along with this some interesting reaction (apparently links arent allowed in comments here, but the archive is at ndtceda.com and the discussion is from March 2003 in the thread “Karl Rove’s debate roots”)
interestingly, it is now common for high school and college policy debaters to cart around 3 or more large plastic storage tubs on a dolly - although 8.5×11 paper has overtaken 3×5 cards.
posted by michael on 7-9-2008 at 8:12 pm
The only thing I want to know about Rove is that he’s dead.
If I believed in the devil it’d be him.
posted by BassMan on 7-11-2008 at 11:53 am
Those ancedotes don’t show that he was a great debator - just a great manipulator. Which, isn’t actually a surprise. His tactics fit quite well with the current administration - instead of having a skill, he plays games of distraction. Not something to be proud of.
posted by Dawn on 7-19-2008 at 9:28 pm