When a player gets inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame, museum officials reserve the right to select which team’s hat appears on his Cooperstown plaque. Until recently, the Hall of Fame would generally honor a player’s wishes, even if the team he chose wasn’t the one for which he left the most indelible mark. Goose Gossage being enshrined as a member of the New York Yankees this weekend is a relative no-brainer, but they’re not all so easy.

We’ve blurred the hats on the Cooperstown plaques of 14 Hall of Famers. Do you know which team’s cap each legend is wearing?

Take the Quiz: Hall of Fame Hats