mental_floss magazine
SUBSCRIBE >
GIFT SUBSCRIPTIONS >
DIGITAL SUBSCRIPTIONS >
subscriber services >
By Christa Wagner
Sure, it may seem silly, but, comic books mean something. Soldiers used dog-eared copies of Captain America to keep their spirits up in WWII. The Green Lantern and Green Arrow made kids actually think about issues like racism and heroin. And millions gasped when they heard the news that Superman died. In fact, the vibrant medium is so often pegged as children’s pulp, or fun for the feeble-minded, that people tend to forget that comics have actually grown with and continued to reflect the spirit of our times.
Before the release of Action Comics #1, the detective/reporter/adventurer-with-alter-ego formula had been used to create countless characters like Flash Gordon and The Shadow—leading men who were heroes, but not superheroes. That all changed with two 23-year-old graphic illustrators from Cleveland, Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster. Together, they created Superman, a hero that came onto the scene hoisting automobiles over his head, speed-walking past moving trains, and effortlessly hopping from building to building. Kids around the world dropped their jaws and allowances, begging for more. Little did they know, Superman had almost been swept off the drawing room floor. Siegel and Shuster drew the original strip in 1934, and for four years tried to sell it to newspaper syndicates with no luck. Finally, in 1938, DC Comics editor Vin Sullivan fished it out of a pile of rejected strips and ran it, changing the history of comic books forever.
Issue #27 marked the debut of Bob Kane and Bill Finger’s comic creation, Batman. Batman didn’t have any super-powers like Superman, but he was tricked out on gadgets. Working under the cover of darkness, Batman appeared more sinister than other comic heroes (or villains, for that matter), and yet simultaneously served as an identifiable flesh-and-blood human. Ultimately, Batman introduced a completely new characteristic to superherodom: fallibility.
In the Golden Age, superheroes were all the rage. So to scratch America’s newest itch, Marvel Comics introduced three incredible, death-defying heroes: the Human Torch, the Submariner and the Angel. If anything, the rapid introduction of new characters and publishers to the line-up revealed that comic books were fantastically appealing to people, especially kids, who could afford to buy them with their allowances. This meant that, for the first time in American history, companies could mass-market directly to children.
After the success of Action Comics #1, it became apparent that Superman needed his own comic book, which is how Superman #1 became the first title devoted to a single comic character. Kids’ pajamas and bed sheets would never be the same again, but neither would America. Superman was the first incarnation of a new type of hero: an omnipotent do-gooder doubling (admirably) as a working class man. With Superman at the helm, comic books entered their Golden Age.
No discussion of comics can begin without mentioning Richard F. Outcault’s “The Yellow Kid,” which ran as a series of strips and panels in The New York World and later in The New York Herald. Its star was hardly a superhero, though; the Yellow Kid was a short boy with huge ears, a bald head, and a signature yellow nightshirt. Regardless, the comic became so popular that competing papers started relying on it to boost sales. The strip even spawned the term “yellow journalism,” which refers to a brand of sensationalist newspapers. Then, in March 1897, a Yellow Kid compilation was released, and it became the first comic strip printed as a pulp magazine. (The one pictured is magazine #2). But what’s the true measure of commercial success? Products galore. The Yellow Kid was the first comic book character to be merchandized on things like t-shirts, gum and even kitchen appliances.
With the world at war, Americans desperately needed a superhero who would convince them that good could triumph over evil. Captain America jumped into the ring fist-first, delivering a swift punch to Hitler’s jaw on the cover of his first comic (no veiled political overtones here!). The Captain was on a die-hard crusade against Nazism, fighting his nemesis Red Skull, who, according to the comic, was personally appointed to the post by Hitler himself. And although Captain America wasn’t the first overtly patriotic superhero (The Shield had donned a similar star-spangled getup a year prior), he was the most popular. Be sure to note the title on this one: Captain America was the first character to be given his own book without being tested in another comic first.
Although this marked the second time a superhero had gotten his own title, Batman #1 is most important for making celebrities out of Batman’s nemeses, the Joker and Catwoman, whom he meets here for the first time. Batman had also recently teamed up with Robin the Boy Wonder to create the world’s most dynamic duo (and first superhero sidekick!). But since Batman was injured more often than his comic book brethren (he was only human after all), he sometimes had to hand over his cases to his good buddy Robin.
This issue launched the enormously popular Green Lantern, the first “everyday guy” to luck into superhero powers. Engineer Alan Scott inherited his new identity after a) finding a lantern made of alien metal, b) making a ring from the metal, then c) logically pressing said ring against said lantern to amazing effect … thus, gaining powers over everything except (strangely enough) wood.
Wonder Woman first appeared in All Star Comics #8 as a kind of proto-feminist figure, fighting for wronged women in a man-made world. Until that point, the women of comics were mainly girlfriends or secretaries looking to be rescued. Though dually praised and criticized for her role, just a few months after Wonder Woman’s debut, a poll crowned her the readers’ “favorite superhero,” beating her closest male rival by a margin of 40-1.
The star of Whiz Comics #2 was Billy Batson, a congenial kid who could transform himself into a super-powered hero called Captain Marvel by uttering “SHAZAM!” (an acronym invoking the powers of Solomon, Hercules, Atlas, Zeus, Achilles and Mercury). Young boys everywhere became fascinated with Captain Marvel, and the fantasy of transforming themselves into a superhero and back again.
The Silver Age ushered comics out of the 1950s Comics Code doldrums with a brand-spanking-new approach to storytelling.

In 1961, Marvel writers Stan Lee and Jack Kirby decided that flawless superheroes weren’t very, well, realistic. So Lee, Kirby and artist Steve Ditko created The Fantastic Four, The Incredible Hulk and The Amazing Spider-Man. These characters had super-instincts, but they also had some personal problems. In the old days, readers knew exactly who the good guys were and rooting for them was easy. But by the Silver Age, readers got a chance to consider more mundane stuff, like what would happen if Clark Kent and Lois Lane wanted to have a baby.
When Peter Parker, a nerdy, orphaned teenager, gets bitten by a radioactive spider, it turns out to be a good thing. As Spider-Man, Parker has “the proportionate strength and agility” of a spider. And while his smarts and strict ethics should have made him a hero even before he had super-powers, his triumph as an underdog helped make “Spidey” one of the most beloved superheroes of all time.
Here, Marvel introduces one of the first African-American superheroes, the Falcon. By day, the Falcon is Harlem social worker Sam Wilson, who has a cautious civil rights platform that discourages black separatism and militancy. The appeal of Captain America, which had a political allegiance that leaned a little to the right, was considerably bolstered by his introduction.
Stan Lee’s X-Men comics made their debut in the Silver Age, but their popularity grew as the years went on. The X-Men are unique in the comic universe in that they are inexplainably born with mutant powers and are severely persecuted as a result. While the team has survived various incarnations over the years, the storyline was slyly created in part to address social issues of prejudice and persecution in way that would get past the Comics Code censors.
After World War II, superhero comics wavered in popularity, disappearing into the underground in part due to the publication of Frederick Wortham’s The Seduction of the Innocent. Wortham’s book warned parents that comic books corrupted kids and made them violent. Comic publishers were sent reeling but recovered quickly with a self-imposed censorship law called the Comics Code Authority. More than a cautionary label, the code ensured that any comic bearing its insignia would be completely free of questionable content.
The chronological boundaries of the next era in comics are ambiguous, but 1970s are considered to be the Bronze Age of comics, with the 1980s generally accepted as the Modern Age — a time characterized by new genres, Marvel/DC cross-over issues, and new titles with the same old heroes.
Amid the civil rights and Vietnam protests of the time, DC Comics found the perfect way to tap into the social climate of the country and boost their sagging sales: by pairing up their conservative vigilante, the Green Lantern, with the left-leaning hero, the Green Arrow. Introduced just a year before, the Green Arrow expanded the scope of storytelling to include relevant social and political issues and capture the idealism of the youth movements of the decade. In the 13 titles that followed, the duo tackled difficult topics including racism, environmental damage and even heroin addiction. Although the Comics Code Authority frowned upon drug-related themes (like when Speedy, Green Arrow’s aptly named sidekick, faced his addiction), the New York Times lauded the title for ushering in a new sense of “relevance” for comics.
Look closely and you’ll notice this cover is missing the Comics Code Authority stamp of approval. Until this point, ignoring the CCA smacked of commercial suicide, but Marvel saw no ethical problem in dealing openly with the dangers of drugs and stuck to its guns. As with the Green Lantern/Green Arrow comics, publishers began to stand up to the CCA and publish issues without their approval. This, however, was the first mainstream one to do so.
The character Wolverine (later famously attached to the X-Men) made his debut in this Incredible Hulk title. Wolverine, along with The Punisher, signaled the arrival of a new type of hero: the anti-hero. Emotionally imbalanced, the vengeful Wolverine didn’t mind killing villains in the name of good or regularly spilling blood in the name of justice.
While pulp “sword and sorcery” stories had been around for decades, it wasn’t until Marvel’s recreation of adventure-book hero Conan the Barbarian that comic publishers began to embrace these older fantasy themes. In fact, Conan inspired a whole slew of sorcery titles, including Marvel’s Kull the Conqueror and DC’s The Warlord, creating an alternative genre for comic book fans who’d grown weary of traditional superheroes in tights.
In 1976, it finally happened: Marvel and DC, the two giants (and rivals) of the industry, united forces to produce this oversized issue. Wide-eyed fans the world over were found salivating, knowing their prayers had been answered. While the title wasn’t the first collaboration between the comic companies (they’d teamed up once before to work on a Wizard of Oz book), it was the first major comic book crossover, a gimmick that guaranteed robust sales.
While there are tons of artists and titles we’d love to highlight (everyone from Daniel Clowes to publishing houses like Dark Horse and Malibu) we just couldn’t finish without dropping these names.
Crude, scathing and obscene, Zap Comix epitomized the underground comic. Its creators intentionally spelled comix with an ‘x’ to accentuate the X-rated nature of the book, separating itself from the mainstream. But lewd content wasn’t Zap’s only distinguishing feature. The writers experimented with dream sequences and stream-of-consciousness and embraced storytelling in its most experimental forms. Zap is also famous (and infamous) for introducing the artist Robert Crumb (creator of Fritz the Cat and the subject of the critically acclaimed 1994 documentary, “Crumb”) to the masses.
Art Spiegelman’s Maus became the first comic book to receive the Pulitzer Prize, bestowing a new level of legitimacy on the medium. This graphic novel illustrates the plight and persecution of Jews during the Holocaust, as told to Spiegelman by his father (a survivor). Maus crossed the line between comic books and mainstream books, inventing the genre of graphic novels. Today, Spiegelman is generally confined to that category, but it’s impossible to deny the impact he’s had on the world of comics.
Referred to as Manga, Japanese comics account for over a third of the nation’s published books. And though Akira wasn’t the first Japanese comic export, it’s probably been the most influential, telling the striking and poignant tale of a child psychic in post-World War III (yes, three) Tokyo. Creator Katsuhiro Otomo’s influence on comics helped open the gates for the Western popularity of “Pokemon” and “Sailor Moon,” but Akira remains his claim to fame.
In 1990, Marvel granted “favored son” status to its artist Todd McFarlane, giving him his own Spider-Man title to write. McFarlane proved worthy. Using nine different covers, Spider-Man #1 became the best-selling comic to date. Not willing to part with his own creations, McFarlane ended up leaving Marvel with a number of well-known artists (and a few ideas up his sleeve) to form Image Comics, which allowed artists to retain the licensing rights to their ideas. The company thrived from the get-go with McFarlane’s other famous superhero comic, Spawn.
Superman dies?! Yup. The unthinkable happens in 1993 with the release of Superman #75. Millions snatched up the comic to read about the death of America’s first superhero. Conveniently, some copies even came packaged with black armbands to mourn the loss. Of course, long-time comic fans were already anticipating his soap-operatic reprise, but the general public thought it was surely the real thing. When the story finally resumed, four new characters emerged, each claiming to be the true incarnation of the dead superhero.
Just like any list, we were forced to leave plenty of favorites off. Watchmen? Persepolis? If you’ve got comics we need to write up for part 2, be sure to include them in the comments below.
Shhh…super secret special for blog readers.
C’mon… Mentioning that you left out Watchmen doesn’t make it right to leave it out!
posted by Triseult on 7-19-2008 at 2:13 pm
I say “yes” to Watchmen, and this was an amazing post.
posted by Johnny Cat on 7-19-2008 at 2:15 pm
The Watchmen has my vote, as does any issue of the Sandman series.
posted by Schmidtty on 7-19-2008 at 2:35 pm
There’s a slight and misleading discrepancy in the description of the Green Arrow. Green Arrow was, in fact, updated and redesigned as a populist social crusader in 1969. However, the character was introduced in 1941, along with his sidekick, Speedy.
posted by dagwud on 7-19-2008 at 3:09 pm
“Watchmen” is a definite must for this kind of list, as well as “Dark Knight Returns”.
posted by Adam on 7-19-2008 at 3:35 pm
I think Frank Miller’s Dark Knight returns is an obvious choice to be included.
posted by bigciafan on 7-19-2008 at 4:26 pm
Dude, Sandman and the Buffy Season 8 comics. That’s great stuff right there.
posted by Rosalie on 7-19-2008 at 5:54 pm
Johnny the Homocidal Maniac or Squee by Jhonen Vasquez…a bit unconventional, but still great.
posted by Derek on 7-19-2008 at 6:05 pm
I notice you didn’t mention any of the many “kiddy” comics, like Richie Rich, or Little Lulu. I used to read the Richie Rich comics hoping some villian would finally get the brat!
Nowadays I think the Japanese manga are most entertaining. I have a soft spot for Inuyasha in particular.
posted by Pam on 7-19-2008 at 8:17 pm
THOR #126 for the greatest cover ever-illustrated by Jack Kirby and Vince Colletta. 1st issue that THOR got his own book, formerly featured in Journey into Mystery.
posted by Ed Blewett on 7-19-2008 at 8:34 pm
++ to Sandman. Otherwise great list.
posted by ac on 7-19-2008 at 8:55 pm
Gee, you only left out the most highly praised comic of all time, The Watchmen.
posted by Will on 7-19-2008 at 9:21 pm
Batman: Killing Joke. Single greatest comic ever produced.
posted by bily on 7-19-2008 at 10:32 pm
I’m going to put on my Simpsons’ Comic Book Guy goatee here and say that, technically, Watchmen nor The Dark Knight Returns should be on this list because they were not single issues, but mini-series. Could any one single issue of either series be on this list? Sure. But if you’re going for influential individual issues, they don’t really belong here. And, yes, I am splitting hairs.
Now for me, G.I. Joe #21 (AKA “The Silent Issue”), would have fit in nicely near the end of the list. But then, I’m such a nerd I have the entire run of Marvel’s G.I. Joe comics, so maybe I’m biased…
posted by SpaceMonkeyX on 7-19-2008 at 10:33 pm
wheres the pic of Spiegelman? “Maus crossed the line between comic books and mainstream books, inventing the genre of graphic novels. Today, Spiegelman (pictured above, right)” .. sorry but i dont see him, am i missing something? yeah its off topic but i wanna see damnit.. :P
posted by youknow on 7-19-2008 at 10:56 pm
Persepolis by Marjane Satrapi is viewed as literature moreso than a comic book, yet is most definitely in comic book format, and has received worldwide critical approval.
I agree with Sandman and Watchmen, as well.
And for events, I think at least a mention of Crisis on Infinite Earths deserves mention, along with Batman A Death in the Family, since not only did it kill off a major character, but it also left the decision up to the readers.
I also think mentioning the reboot of some Marvel characters with Knights and Ultimates is worth mentioning, in throwing the rules out the window. And Wolverine: Origins, since they were kept secret for so long.
posted by burnsbothends on 7-19-2008 at 11:22 pm
you forgot Cerebus the aardvark you meandering dolt!!
posted by LD on 7-19-2008 at 11:48 pm
++Sandman
++Watchman
++Dark knight returns
and I’d like to add Jeff Smith’s Bone!!
posted by Matthew Middleton on 7-19-2008 at 11:54 pm
“The Killing Joke” (for its very dark and very relevant Joker/Batman face-off)
posted by Matt on 7-20-2008 at 12:23 am
Who made this list??? Superman 75 was garbage and made meaningless within a year if you’re going to have this on the list you might as well put the equally meaningless Batman Knightfall series. Spiderman 1 was over hyped commercial trash(how many covers???). Seduction of the Innocent wasn’t even a comic book!!!
Where are…
Watchmen?
The Dark Knight Returns?
Sandman?
even Uncanny X-Men 137 should be on this list over some of this other stuff.
posted by Fin on 7-20-2008 at 12:24 am
The Sandman, Watchmen, and Johnny the Homicidal Maniac.
Mostly the first two, but JtHM is still a gem.
posted by Erik on 7-20-2008 at 1:43 am
Watchmen belongs on the list because it won the hugo award. Dark Knight was great but not a cultural shift. I would suggest that Warrior, which debuted V for Vendetta and marked Miracleman’s return, deserves a mention, as does 2000AD for bringing punk to comics… excpet that I’m a grown up and far too mature to know anything about the subject.
posted by simplex on 7-20-2008 at 2:00 am
invisibles.
posted by blissamerica on 7-20-2008 at 2:39 am
As far as current era graphic novels go, I think we’d be remiss in not giving THE LOSERS its due.
posted by Logan on 7-20-2008 at 4:21 am
You may want to consider Flex Mentallo and Invisibles from Grant Morrison.
posted by STY on 7-20-2008 at 7:15 am
Watchmen, Dark Knight but no mention of 2000AD or Eagle
posted by monster74 on 7-20-2008 at 7:38 am
Watchmen, Sandman, Dark Knight, and Persepolis – definitely worth a mention. How about Y: The Last Man, Fables, or Barry Ween, Boy Genius?
posted by Jessi on 7-20-2008 at 9:48 am
Frank Miller’s Daredevil changed comics in a big way. I’d also have to mention Steranko’s Nick Fury, Agent of S.H.I.E.L.D and Captain America, Neal Adams’ X-Men, and Kirby’s New Gods/Mr. Miracle/Forever People. If you’re going to talk worldwide and across time, there’s Little Nemo and Asterix to consider.
posted by Rick on 7-20-2008 at 11:31 am
what about Tin Tin??? Rick, I agree with Asterix too!
posted by Cass on 7-20-2008 at 12:27 pm
Watchmen for sure. I’m really surprised that it didn’t make it here! The Dark Knight Returns and The Killing Joke should be on the next one.
posted by Kieran on 7-20-2008 at 12:29 pm
Why not Tin Tin? Asterix? Bandes Dessinées are really popular in France.
posted by Timothy on 7-20-2008 at 1:31 pm
I’m going to have to agree that leaving out The Sandman stuff is a travesty. Gaiman gave the genre a legitimacy it had been missing.
Also, what about Archie? Classifying a woman as a “Betty” or a “Veronica” still goes on to this day.
posted by Kathy on 7-20-2008 at 1:52 pm
The theme is “important comic books”, not to be confused with “this was garbage” or “this is the best comic ever”.
“Watchmen” certainly belongs on the list, and I would argue that “Killing Joke” does not. It is a good story, but I’m not sure why it would qualify as “important”.
My candidates, off the top of my head:
* Showcase #4 (introducing Barry Allen as Flash), bringing superheroes back to the mainstream after post-WWII’s sluggish sales. Many other revivals followed: Hal Jordan as Green Lantern, Ray Palmer as Atom, and so on.
* All-Star Comics #3, the first full-length team-up story featuring characters from a regular anthology title.
* Superman #76, bringing Superman and Batman together for the first time. They had shared the cover of World’s Finest before, but this served the model for later WF teams-ups deemed necessary buy inflation and lower page counts.
* Superman: The Man of Steel by John Byrne, 1986. Forget everything you knew before — let’s start completely from scratch. (This was made possible by the also-important Crisis on Infinite Earths.)
* X-Men #94, expanding the cast and scope to add “relevance” to great success.
* Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, bringing wild attention to “independent” publishers
* Alpha Flight #106, revealing for the first time that a well-established character (Northstar) is gay.
* Pep Comics #22, introducing Archie
* Mad #24, now officially a magazine to avoid the standards of the Comics Code Authority
* Understanding Comics by Scott McCloud and Will Eisner’s “Comics and Sequential Art”, explaining how comics work. It’s not as easy as it looks.
posted by Jeff on 7-20-2008 at 2:36 pm
One title should have made this list IMHO – Wendy and Richard Pini’s (WaRP Graphics) “ElfQuest” which set the standard for Independent titles in the 1970’s and 1980’s – (See Adventure Quarterly #1)
To date there simply hasn’t been anything like it in terms of Artwork or Storyline. This title is HUGE and anyone who loves the genre will be sorely missing out without at least a passing glance at ElfQuest…
posted by Robert Fernando on 7-20-2008 at 5:54 pm
Since Persepolis was mentioned, I’m going to assume that it’s fair for me to name Fun Home. Beautifully written, amazing artwork, it’s among the best books I’ve read.
posted by Jessica on 7-20-2008 at 7:16 pm
Umm…
I used to like *cough*The Phantom*cough*
posted by Steve on 7-20-2008 at 7:34 pm
Frank Miller’s Sin City was awesome!!!
posted by Andy on 7-21-2008 at 12:38 pm
Planetary is a great series. Must read for all comic fans.
posted by Tim on 7-21-2008 at 3:43 pm
I love that there are hundreds of single issues and OGNs that could and should be on that list!
Don’t call me crazy before you think about it, but Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles #1 deserves some consideration. It changed the indie scene in the 80s and helped elevate black and white comics in the eyes of consumers. It started a franchise that would move into T.V. and movies as well as toys and video games. It may have lost it’s relevance over the years, but TMNT left a huge impression on the comics industry.
posted by Chris Neseman on 7-22-2008 at 1:21 pm
Oh good. I can see I got here JUST in time for the millions of internet nerds to weigh in with their opinions.
Might as well add my own…
-Bone
-The Dark Knight Returns
-The Infinity Gauntlet
-Neil Gaimans “The Sandman”
-Wolverine: Origins
gah…and about 100 others…
posted by BenZarius on 7-22-2008 at 8:32 pm
Sandman is a must-add.
posted by Raymond on 7-22-2008 at 11:20 pm
As so many others have said: The Watchmen, Batman Year 1 and the Dark Knight Returns. But I have to add the Daredevil Born Again series and (MOST IMPORTANTLY) the Alan Moore Swamp Thing.
posted by Bret on 7-23-2008 at 1:52 am
“Yellow Journalism” was not derived from the “Yellow Kid.” “Yellow Journalism” is derived from the cheap paper most newspapers were printed on which yellowed quickly because of the high acid content.
Great post regardless.
Some other things which could/should be recognized:
Daredevil #181- Death of Elektra/Amazing Spiderman #121- The Death of Gwen Stacy- major characters dying in a comic book.
There should be some reference to how writers like Alan Moore and Frank Miller brought a great deal of depth to comics. Did anyone mention Watchmen? (Hehe.) Or how ’bout Return of the Dark Knight?
posted by charley on 7-23-2008 at 9:07 am
For me the one series that is missing is Love and Rockets. The Hernandez brothers comic was an inspiring look at various cultures within one format. I would agree that Watchmen should be there, and 2000ad was and continues to be at the forefront of british Sci-fi comics spawning such characters as Judge Dredd, Halo Jones, Rogue Trooper, DR & Quinch and many many more.
posted by garry clark on 7-23-2008 at 10:08 am
Watchmen (Hugo award winner)
Sandman (World Fantasy Award winner, only comic on the New York Times best seller list).
You don’t leave titles with that kind of credential and clout OFF a list like this. These appealed to an very wide audience. THESE are the kinds of comics that let people know comics aren’t just “children’s pulp” anymore.
Were you asleep when you made this list up? Or just not paying any attention to the medium at all?
posted by ghost on 7-23-2008 at 4:28 pm
Will Eisner’s The Spirit should be on this list. Will Eisner invented many, many of the storytelling techniques that make up the comic book vocabulary. That is why the most prestigious award in comic is named the Eisner.
Also, Eisner’s Contract With God is generally considered to be the first graphic novel, not Art Speigelman’s Maus.
posted by Scott Watson on 7-24-2008 at 6:58 pm
I know this is horribly out of date, but I thought I’d post a rebuttal as seen by comic book fans and creators.
(link is in my name)
posted by xadrian on 7-30-2008 at 9:17 am
showcase #4 marked the start of the silver age.
posted by Julz Saito on 8-4-2008 at 5:59 pm
I wonder if we could get this list reposted and re-vamped on the main page.
Based on the comments and the huge successes of the Batman films, and the upcoming Watchmen film, I would argue that:
- Watchmen
- Sandman (series)
- The Dark Knight Returns
should all be on this list. No mention of any Iron Man titles? How about War Machine from the Iron Man series, another African-American superhero?
posted by Jeffrey Padilla on 11-13-2008 at 4:09 pm
Gotta have Watchmen, Dark Knight Returns, Crisis on Infinite Earths, and Sandman.
Watchmen was praised by Time as one of the top 100 English-language novels, 1923-2005. It was the only comic to do so.
DKR rebooted a flagging Batman character and made him the brooding, darker incarnation popular in Nolan’s movies, a decidedly different take than the popular camp-60’s perception of the Batman. Also had a Superman/Batman battle, which if not “important” per se was undeniably ill.
Crisis was a huge retcon designed to reconcile the several seemingly contradictory realities that had existed up to that point in various Marvel books. The highest-profile attempt to establish and hold steady a publisher-wide continuity.
The Sandman simply showed how comics could approach traditional mythology and theology, while also weaving in characters from comics continuity, to create a logical (if fantastic) existence for loads of familiar faces, from John Constantine to Lucifer to Cain and Abel to Death to Shakespeare. A classic.
As pointed out above, each of these isn’t really a single-issue comic book, but trade paperbacks of collected series. Either way, though, a single issue could be picked from each TPB to best represent the series.
posted by Jay on 12-18-2008 at 6:38 pm
Just sos you know, the green arrow wasn’t introduced in 1969. His first appearance was in More Fun Comics #73 in 1941. Fact check yo.
posted by Dsandwich on 12-29-2008 at 9:27 pm
The Death of Superman is probably my favorite on that list. I have reread it a bunch of times and it still pulls at me emotionally every time.
Watchmen should be on that list too.
posted by Comic Cat on 9-26-2009 at 6:25 pm