Rob Lammle
8 Secessionist Movements in American History
by Rob Lammle - October 14, 2008 - 2:40 PM

Rebellious-Regions.jpg

We all know about the Confederate states leaving the Union. But that was far from the only secessionist movement in American history. Here are some rebellious regions you won’t find in too many history books.

1. The Kingdom of Beaver Island

Strang.jpgBeaver Island, a small island in Lake Michigan, became the home of Mormon leader James Strang and his followers—called Strangites—in 1848. Two years later, Strang declared himself king of the church—complete with crown, scepter, robe, and a harem of 15 wives. However, most of the island’s inhabitants were his followers, so he essentially became King of Beaver Island. The power got to his head, and he began forcing his rule onto the non-believers, causing some violence between the two factions. In 1856, the USS Michigan pulled into the harbor and invited Strang aboard. As he was walking towards the ship, he was shot in the back by disgruntled followers, who then ran up the gangplank and escaped. Adding to the mysterious circumstances, the assassins were set ashore on nearby Mackinac Island and never charged for their crime. Shortly after the assassination, angry mobs from surrounding islands eventually forced the Strangites from their homes, thus ending the short-lived Kingdom of Beaver Island.

2. The State of Superior

Concern over a perceived lack of interest from the Michigan state government, the people of the Upper Peninsula (U.P.), affectionately known as “Yoopers,” have been trying to secede and form the State of Superior since as far back as 1897. The movement gained momentum after 1957 when a bridge connecting the U.P. region to Lower Michigan made it easier for southern “Trolls” (people who live “below the bridge”) and Yoopers to mingle. This animosity continued into the mid-1980s, when 20,000 signatures were collected and submitted to the state for a secession request. However, the number was shy of the 36,000 required, and the request subsequently denied. The secessionist drive lives on today, as numerous grassroots organizations are trying to muster support for another official attempt at an independent U.P. Until that day comes, though, the Yoopers and Trolls will just have to try to get along.

3. The Great Republic of Rough and Ready

rough-and-ready-flag.jpgRough and Ready, California, was a mining town founded in 1849 by the Rough and Ready Company of Wisconsin. As the town’s population rapidly exploded to 3,000, lawlessness was on the rise—and the U.S. government was not much help squelching the rampant crime. Additionally, a new federal tax on mining operations added fuel to the region’s civil unrest. Seeing little support from Washington, on April 7, 1850, the townspeople voted to secede from the Union.

But just three months later, as the Fourth of July approached, The Great Republic of Rough and Ready wanted to have a celebration (which seems odd considering they were no longer, technically, Americans). When nearby Nevada City wouldn’t sell liquor to “foreign miners,” it was decided that maybe America wasn’t so bad after all. The townspeople voted themselves back into the Union on the very same day and the party went off as planned.

4. The Conch Republic

conch-flag.jpgIn the early-1980s, the U.S. Border Patrol set up a checkpoint at the entrance to the Florida Keys in an effort to stop illegal drugs and immigrants. The time to check everyone’s identification at the checkpoint resulted in a 20-mile traffic jam that turned tourists away, thus damaging the economy in the Keys. After numerous legal attempts to have the checkpoint removed, on April 23, 1982, Key West mayor Dennis Wardlow declared the Florida Keys were seceding from the Union.

Moments later, now-Prime Minister Wardlow symbolically declared war on the U.S. by breaking a stale piece of Cuban bread over the head of a man dressed in a U.S. Navy uniform. One minute later, Wardlow turned to the Admiral in charge of the U.S. Naval Base at Key West and surrendered, thus ending the Conch Republic’s Civil Rebellion. He then immediately asked for $1 billion in federal aid to help rebuild his war-torn nation’s economy. While officially the Republic conch-coins.jpgonly existed for one minute, the tongue-in-cheek spirit of the rebellion lives on. Today you can buy Conch Republic citizen and diplomatic passports (both of which have been used for international travel, though they are not intended to be official documents) and even an official flag of the republic (complete with the awesome motto, “We seceded where others failed”). The community has even minted a series of limited edition one-conch dollar coins that can be used as legal tender while in the Keys.

5. The State of Absaroka

Feeling that the Democratic southern half of Wyoming was not working in conjunction with the rest of the state, a secessionist movement was launched by northern Republicans in 1939 to create a new state that would better serve its more conservative population. This state, Absaroka—so named after the nearby mountain range—was to be made up of northern Wyoming, southeast Montana, and the western region of South Dakota. While the secessionist movement was never very large or pursued through legal channels, that didn’t stop A. R. Swickard, the street commissioner of Sheridan, WY, from appointing himself governor of the “state.”

MissAbsaroka1939.jpg

The movement went so far as to press Absaroka license plates and crown a Miss Absaroka beauty queen. Absaroka could even brag about a visit from a foreign dignitary, King Haakon VII of Norway (though he was officially visiting Wyoming and just happened to be in Absaroka).

Despite all of the hoopla, the state never came to be, and now, so many years later, the intent of the secessionist movement is in question. Some believe there was a genuine attempt to create a new state, while others say it was just a fun way for cowboys to distract themselves during tough economic times.

6. The State of Jefferson

jefferson-flag.jpgNorthern California and southern Oregon have been trying to merge since 1852. The attempts have been met with mixed results, though the “State of Jefferson” movement of 1941 came closest to making it happen. The region felt it was being ignored by their respective state legislatures, so in response the people created the “State of Jefferson Citizen’s Committee” to explore the possibilities of secession. The group began stopping cars on Highway 99 to hand out the state’s “Proclamation of Independence,” a pamphlet outlining the grievances they held and the solutions they proposed. To help rally their cause, they developed a state flag made up of a gold miner’s pan with two black X’s inside, representing the double-cross they felt the Oregon and California state governments had pulled.

On December 4, 1941, Judge John Childs was elected governor of Jefferson in the state’s temporary capital of Yreka, CA. The event was filmed by numerous newsreel companies who were set to air the footage during the week of December 8th. History had other plans, as the Japanese bombed Pearl Harbor the day before the big premiere. Driven by a sense of national obligation, the Jefferson secession was put aside and never really regained momentum. While the official movement might have died out, the residents of this region still hold the concept in their hearts, with many identifying themselves even today as the population of the great state of Jefferson.

7. The McDonald Territory

Noel, Missouri, located in McDonald County in the far southwest corner of the Show Me State, has been a popular tourist destination for many years. Therefore, when the Missouri State Highway Commission left Noel off their annual “Family Vacationland” map in 1961, the region was not happy pleased. To display their dissatisfaction, McDonald County drew up papers of secession and presented them to the state legislature, declaring itself the independent McDonald Territory. The county went so far as to elect officials, form a territorial militia, and even printed up visas that were issued to visitors so they could travel throughout the territory.

mcdonald-stamp.jpgPerhaps the most lasting impression were the thousands of McDonald Territory stamps that were printed and sold throughout the area. While most agree that the secession was done purely for publicity, the state of Missouri wasn’t necessarily happy about the type of publicity it was garnering. So in order to end this mock rebellion, the state declared that state employee retirement pension payments would be suspended for McDonald County, all current state employees would be fired, and all state funding would be withheld. Needless to say, McDonald Territory surrendered and returned to being simply McDonald County, Missouri, once again.

And here’s one more secessionist movement recently covered here on the _floss:

8. Alaska

For decades, a well-organized separatist movement has campaigned to turn America’s largest state into its own nation. The bitterness dates back to 1958, when Alaska’s citizens were given a simple yes-or-no vote on statehood. Many Alaskans felt they were denied more options on the issue, prompting a land developer named Joe Vogler to organize a re-vote that would offer Alaskans four possibilities—remain a territory, become a state, take commonwealth status, or become a separate nation.

AIP.jpgUsing the vote as his platform, Vogler ran for governor in 1974—and soon made a habit of it. With colorful slogans such as, “I’m an Alaskan, not an American. I’ve got no use for America or her damned institutions,” Vogler spearheaded the Alaskan Independence Party (AIP), and his campaign has twice topped 5 percent of the vote. More surprisingly, former U.S. interior secretary Wally Hickel got elected governor on the AIP ticket in 1990. Unfortunately for the party, Hickel only ran on the ticket because he lost the Republican primary. Never a supporter of the plebiscite idea, Hickel left the AIP and rejoined the Republicans in 1994.

Today, the AIP continues to draw about 4 percent of voters statewide. And in 2006, Alaska took part in the first-ever North American Secessionist Convention, joining other groups from Vermont, Hawaii, and the South. As for Vogler, he was murdered in 1993—reportedly the result of an argument over a business deal. On a brighter note, honoring his wish to never be buried in U.S. soil, Vogler was laid to rest in Canada’s Yukon Territory.

–Jeff Fleischer (From ’9 Modern-Day Independence Movements’)

Rob Lammle is probably the only cartographer you’ll ever meet who has an English degree. Read more on his own site, spacemonkeyx.com.

See also…

The Map With Only 38 States
*
The Confederacy’s Plan to Conquer Latin America

*
The Tone-Deaf Man Who Invented Karaoke
*
7 Crafty Zoo Escapes
*
Money for (Almost) Nothing: Big Paychecks for Little Work
*
Forgotten American Border Disputes
*
The George Costanza Candy Identification Quiz

Click here to get a Risk-Free issue of mental_floss magazine
Comments (21)
  1. Damn, Americans are stupid.

  2. Every so often, there will be an op-ed piece in some of the local papers about western New York seceeding from the rest of New York. Essentially, Buffalo, Rochester and Syracuse are sick of all their tax dollars being shipped down to New York City with virtually nothing coming back to the other cities. As a resident of western New York, I don’t think it’s a bad idea.

  3. A tiny section of northern Minnesota called Northwest Angle has raised interest in seceding into Canada, since it is entirely separated from the US mainland by a lake, and has more of an interest in Manitoba’s fishing laws than Minnesota’s (It’s stuck between the borders of Minnesota, Manitoba, and Ontario). That combined with annoying border-crossing issues makes you really think, “Hmm. They have a point.”

  4. I live in the state of Jefferson. Just thirty miles from Yreka. I wish it was really.

  5. Being a Jeffersonian myself, I think we should absolutely be allowed to secede. California’s too big anyway.

    And then we would have half a sales tax…

  6. The Act of Admission of Texas into the Union allows my home state to divide itself. If things had gone as planned in 1915, I would not be from the state of Texas, but rather the state of Jefferson (currently the Texas Panhandle). That could have been kind of confusing if the other State of Jefferson had also truly seceded.

  7. Besides people don’t quite get wear we live. They don’t understand that it snows here. Not all of Jefferson, but in some towns it sure does.

  8. The Maritime Republic of Eastport has been trying to secede from the city of Annapolis forever…self admittedly a pub inspired movement. They have a tug of war over the river each year to prove their point….

  9. Don’t forget the “Free State of Winston”.
    During the Civil War, most of the citizens of Winston County in northwest Alabama refused to recognize the Confederacy. It all started when the county’s representative to the state secession convention landed himself in jail for refusing to sign Alabama’s ordinance of secession. Throughout the war, Winston County managed to avoid the yolk of Confederate control due to it’s isolated nature. This shunning of the Confederacy became the inspiration for “The Incident at Looney’s Tavern”, the state of Alabama’s official outdoor musical drama.

  10. In regards to the Conch Republic, citizens who owned sea planes “attacked” Fort Jefferson by bombing it with stale cuban bread. However, the National Park service requested the “bombings” stop because it was increasing the rat population on the island.

  11. there’s some people out in west texas who still believe that the state was illegally annexed by the US and is therefore still an independent nation. they have their own radio stations and newspapers and stuff.

    and to answer nutmeag, the constituition of texas holds no such provision that it can secede, although it is “a free and independent State, subject only to the Constitution of the United States.”

    reCaptcha: valiantly watched

  12. There was also a movement for 14 counties in western Illinois to form the state of Forgottonia in the late 1960′s and early 1970′s. Wikipedia has an article.

  13. The native Hawaiians have been trying to secede from the U.S. for years. Their biggest attempt was in the 90′s from what I remembered, when they tried to make Hawaii a sovereign nation.

  14. I’d check out the Burr Conspiracy. Aaron Burr, Vice President under Jefferson (in his first term) and shooter of Alexander Hamilton also tried to instigate a war between the U.S., Spain, and England in 1804-06.

    He was attempting to trick the U.S. into declaring war which would make it technically legal for him to take military action on American soil, which would allow him to seize land in what is now Texas and part of Oklahoma and create his own monarchy.

    He also got the commander of the U.S. Army, James Wilkinson, to help as well as future war hero and president Andrew Jackson to build flotilla rafts that were going to be used to lay siege to New Orleans.

  15. The fiftieth anniversary of the McDonald Territory secession attempt will be in 2011. Philatelic commemoration is planned and discussed at Spring River Local Post’s page at http://www.qsl.net/kg0yh/mcdonald.htm
    Some ideas are to recreate a Pony Express ride from Noel to Neosho, with carriage of souvenir mail, marked for the event appropriately.

  16. You also for got the great state of Lincoln, (Eastern Washington, Eastern Oregon, and the Idaho panhandle) petitions come around every few years to allow us to seceed from our western (or southern) halves.

  17. I remember the Key West thing. It was hilarious!

  18. I would totally move to Jefferson.

  19. You missed “the lost state of Franklin”, which was located in what is now eastern Tennessee.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_of_Franklin

  20. Interesting article! I am currently blogging about some similar topics, including the State of Franklin and the State of Deseret – two states that didn’t make the final cut.

    My topic is about how our states got their shapes (I started this research before the History channel aired the beginning of their series). I find this stuff really interesting and enjoy the fact that you accidentally learn some American history along the way.

    http://www.lynngarthwaiteblog.com

  21. Winneconne, a small community in Winnebago County in east-central Wisconsin, seceded from the State of Wisconsin back in 1967 after it had inadvertently been left off of the official state highway map for that year.  A secret committee began formulated a plan to secede from Wisconsin, set up toll gates on local roads, begin annexation of nearby communities (starting with the city of Oshkosh) to form a Sovereign State of Winneconne, and declare war on the United States.  An alternative plan, consisting of annexation by another state — preferably one with better weather — was also considered.

    A proclamation was issued on July 21, 1967, naming village president James Coughlin to be president of the new state of Winneconne, and their sovereignty was supposedly recognized by Canada.  Wisconsin Governor Warren P. Knowles then entered into negotiations with the former village officials, and as a result Winneconne rejoined the State of Wisconsin at 12:01 AM on July 22, 1967.

    An annual “Sovereign State Days” celebration still commemorates the event.

    -”BB”-

Comment

commenting policy