Where Knowledge Junkies Get Their Fix
McAfee Secure sites help keep you safe from identity theft, credit card fraud, spyware, spam, viruses and online scams
Stacy Conradt
The Quick 10: Sleepy Hollow (and its Legend)
by Stacy Conradt - October 30, 2008 - 2:29 PM

q10

Aw, tomorrow is Halloween. I mean, it’s exciting, but it’s simultaneously sad. I’m like those people who get the post-wedding blues – you know, you’ve been planning and planning and planning and then the event is over, and you’re left with a void.

I didn’t actually get the post-wedding blues, but I do get the post-Halloween blues. Yes, I’m weird. Anyway, since tomorrow is the last day I can do Halloween posts for another 11 months or so, it’s time to regale you guys with tales of my September trip to Sleepy Hollow. I’ve been holding on to it for over a month! Bear with me; I might be a little long-winded.

irving1. Sleepy Hollow was made famous by Washington Irving, the author of The Legend of Sleepy Hollow and Rip Van Winkle. Actually, he may have named the town – his term “Sleepy Hollow” is the first recorded use of the name. The town was originally called North Tarrytown, but voted to legally change its name to Sleepy Hollow in 1997 (their school athletics teams are called the Horsemen. Love it.). Nearby Irvingtown is named after him – in fact, it took its name while he was still alive, which is a little unusual. Usually those types of things are posthumous. It just goes to show what a beloved character he was in the area. Oh, one other quick Irving fact: in 1807, he coined the term “Gotham” for New York City – it’s an Anglo-Saxon word meaning “Goat’s town.”

map2. The cemetery looks like one cemetery, but it’s actually two and is owned and maintained as two separate entities. There’s the Old Dutch Burying Ground, which is on the grounds of the Old Dutch Church; and there’s Sleepy Hollow Cemetery, which surrounds the Old Dutch property. The people Irving used as his inspiration are located in the Old Dutch Burying Grounds; Irving himself and lots of other illustrious people are located in Sleepy Hollow Cemetery. The two cemeteries put together are huge – about 88 acres. Most of that is Sleepy Hollow Cemetery – the Old Dutch Property is only about three acres.

3. Washington Irving wasn’t really one to reveal the true identity of the people behind his stories, but he wasn’t too difficult to decipher. Most historians think Eleanor Van Tassel Brush was probably the real-life Katrina Van Tassel. Catriena Ecker Van Tessel (Eleanor’s aunt) was the inspiration for the name, obviously, but Eleanor’s life story and demeanor more closely mirrors that of the fictional Katrina.

martling4. Likewise, Brom Bones was a real guy. He’s thought to be modeled after Abraham Martling, the blacksmith in the village at the time Irving lived there. “Brom” is a nickname for Abraham, or at least was at the time. He was a big guy and rode a gigantic black horse similar to the horse in The Legend of Sleepy Hollow.
5. The Headless Horseman. This one… well, Irving was a fiction writer, right? So you can bet that he took some poetic license with this one. But it’s conceivable that this could have happened, so who knows? The story: The farm of Cornelius and Elizabeth Van Tassel was raided by British and Hessian soldiers in November, 1777. When the Van Tassels tried to fight, the soldiers responded by burning down their farmhouse. First, however, they took the inhabitants of the house hostage. While they watched their house burn, Elizabeth noticed that her baby, Leah, was nowhere to be found. She tried to run back into the burning house to find her, but couldn’t. That’s when a Hessian soldier led her to a shed where someone had wrapped the baby up in a blanket and left her, safe and sound. The Van Tassels were so grateful, that when a Hessian soldier missing his head was found in Sleepy Hollow, they insisted on burying him properly in case it was the soldier who had been kind to them. So, if the tale is true, you can see where Washington Irving got his inspiration… even though the “real” Headless Horseman appeared to be at least a partially decent guy.

6. There’s a real Ichabod Crane, to be sure, but you won’t find him in Sleepy Hollow. Ichabod was a Captain in the Army at the same time Irving served. When he needed a name for his arrogant schoolteacher, he thought of Captain Crane. Supposedly, the real Ichabod Crane was less than flattered.

7. Hulda the Witch is a Sleepy Hollow character you won’t find in Legend. Hulda was a real person, an immigrant from Bohemia. She displayed suspicious witch-like behavior by living alone in a cabin in the woods and gathering herbs to make remedies. But she seemed like a perfectly nice lady: when people in town fell ill, she would leave them baskets of her potions and pastes to try to help the healing. People were scared of her anyway, though. However, she became something of a town hero when the British invaded. A group of British soldiers were marching on Albany Post Road, so she and some fellow citizens stopped in their tracks to discourage them from coming any closer. She was a crack shot, I guess, and was able to kill several soldiers before they took her down. People weren’t sure if they should bury her in the Christian Old Dutch Burying Ground, since she was a “witch” and all. When they visited her cabin, they found a will that left all of her assets to women who were war widows. This may have been the deciding factor in the great burial dilemma – the townspeople declared that she was a patriot who died fighting for her community and buried her in the cemetery. Her grave is unmarked, however.

carnegie8. As I mentioned before, there are lots of other people buried at Sleepy Hollow Cemetery. Its most recent famous residents are socialite Brooke Astor and Queen of Mean Leona Helmsley. But you’ll also find Elizabeth Arden, Walter Chrysler, Andrew Carnegie, William Rockefeller and Samuel Gompers (among others). For one of the richest men in history, Carnegie’s stone is surprisingly simple. That’s his pictured. Rockefeller’s, however, is definitely not.

poster9. The Disney version – The Adventures of Ichabod and Mr. Toad, (two separate features, billed as one) came out on October 5, 1949, with Bing Crosby narrating and providing the voice for Brom Bones. The Tim Burton/Johnny Depp version came out on November 19, 1999. This version pays tribute to the Disney version in a couple of spots, if you pay close attention – namely in the scene where Ichabod is crossing the bridge and freaking himself out by misinterpreting all of the forest noises. Although Christopher Walken is the (fabulous) Headless Horseman, he has no lines in the movie… just some noises and grunts and the like.

bridge10. The infamous bridge is no longer there - they’ve built a small bridge in its honor in the cemetery, but at the real spot, this sign is the only thing that remains of the original.

A completely un-Legend-related bit of trivia: Triple H and Stephanie McMahon got married in Sleepy Hollow.

Here’s an added bonus for you: The complete text of Irving’s The Legend of Sleepy Hollow from Gutenberg. Perfect way to bide a little time and spook yourself a little bit.

And here are a few more pictures I thought were creepy or interesting but couldn’t fit into the post:

georgie

old

sinkin

statue

Comments (10)
  1. On a trip to NY and PA a few years ago we stumbled on this place. It is SO very cool; some of the most beautiful grave art I’ve seen. I especially love the masolleums built into the hillside.

  2. great post, Stacy!

    instead of getting the post-halloween blues, try getting pumped about…Veteran’s Day? its just a week and a half away…and then of course the holdidays just come on strong. maybe they can help you through it.

    i just heard from a coworker that his child told him that they aren’t allowed to say “halloween” at (private, christian) school. isnt that the most ridiculous thing you’ve ever heard?

  3. Isn’t it just as ridiculous that they can’t have a Halloween party at school? At least they can’t at my daughter’s school.

  4. The only version of The Legend of Sleepy Hollow I have been exposed to starred Jeff Goldblum as Ichabod Crane. I remember as being slightly comedic. Wish I could see it again!

  5. Washington Irving died on my birthday — Nov. 28! Cool! I didn’t know that. It’s also the date of William Blake’s birth and also Jon Stewart’s.

    Captcha: plot start

  6. Great post! I had forgotten how much I enjoyed the Burton film. Now I must go out and rent it!

  7. I spent my freshman year of college at Marymount University in Tarrytown. It was an all girls school with a wonderfully old campus. I am absolutely certain that campus is haunted. A lot of odd things happened in the dorms. It is now part of Forhdam and has since been named Fordham at Westchester.

    Anyway, I was really excited to learn that Sleepy Hallow was just down the street and was expecting some spectacular Halloween fun. Unfortunately most of the town’s activities were extremely kid friendly and not anywhere close to scary.

    We ended up trick or treating around town and got lots of full size candy bars!

  8. When I was a kid, we almost bought an old house in sleepy hollow but the water from the well was bad.

  9. GEORGIE!!! Freaky…I would have had a panic attack and run away..fast.

    When I was little, we used to have annual Legend of Sleepy Hollow watchings at school. We’d all gather in the auditorium and sit on the floor and the teachers did this mini dance and song Halloween show before handing out lollipops and settling us down to watch the Disney movie.

    I was scared crapless of that movie as a kid. I haven’t seen it in years…*sigh*

  10. Great post… even 2 1/2 months after the fact.

Comment

commenting policy