mental_floss magazine
SUBSCRIBE >
GIFT SUBSCRIPTIONS >
DIGITAL SUBSCRIPTIONS >
subscriber services >
SOLUTION:
Barney won with 100 points, followed by
Otis with 75 points,
Bee with 60 points,
Goober with 45 points, and
Andy with 30 points.
Logic Sequence:
Clue #1. Barney scored 75 or 100; Goober scored 30 or 45.
Clue #2. Otis scored 45 or 75.
Clue #3. Bee scored 60 or 75, Andy scored 30 or 45.
By elimination, Bee scored 60.
Then, referring back to Clue #3, Andy scored 30.
By elimination, Goober scored 45, Otis scored 75, and Barney scored 100.
Doesn’t that mean they played 310 games? Must be a boring town.
posted by pcav on 1-6-2009 at 9:23 am
Only 62 games, pcav, at five points a game. Each player dealt 12 or 13 times, so it might have been a four-hour event, depending on what games they chose. And yes, there’s not much to do in Mayberry once the Sun goes down, unless you like the sound of crickets chirping and frogs croaking.
posted by Sandy on 1-6-2009 at 9:40 am
lol – 4 hours of card-playing is my idea of a perfect evening.
posted by Diana on 1-6-2009 at 10:04 am
Sounds like how I brought in the New Year… On January 1st my family and I played cards for seven hours — breaking only for snacks, drinks and bathroom breaks.
posted by Lindsey on 1-6-2009 at 10:23 am
If you think four hours of game playing is boring, you should come to my family gatherings. With around 100 people showing up, we always have several games of dominoes going that last ALL DAY–and they’re rarely boring.
posted by nutmeag on 1-6-2009 at 11:10 am
must have been playing FISH if Barney was first and Otis second….
posted by olal on 1-6-2009 at 1:03 pm
I figured it out this way:
Andy and Goober both could only score either 30 or 45 points. Andy’s could only be 30 or 45 because his score could only be exactly 30 points below Bee’s (the only pairs of numbers exactly 30 apart are 30/60 and 45/75). Goober’s score could only be 30 or 45 because Barney Scored more than twice as many points as Goober (and the only numbers that fit that category were 30 and 45). This also meant that Barney’s score could only be 75 or 100. Anyway, Since Andy and Goober were 30/45 or 45/30, nobody else could have those amounts. This gives Otis 75 automatically since he had to have an odd number of points and since 45 was the only odd number left. Giving Otis 75 meant that Barney scored 100 (by elimination since he could only have 75 or 100). Back to Bee, she is linked to Andy score by +30 and since 75 was Otis’ score, Bee had to have 60 and Andy (30 under Bee) had 30. This left Goober with 45.
posted by Ian on 1-6-2009 at 2:16 pm
I used to love doing these in Dell Puzzle magazines when I was growing up. You set up a 5×5 grid with the people’s names on the X axis and the points on the Y axis (or vice versa). Fill in the grid with an ‘x’ for each answer that can’t be correct (e.g., Bee can’t have 30 or 45 points, so you enter an x in the corresponding cells) and an ‘o’ for the ones that you’ve determined to be correct. I need to lay out things like this visually in order to solve them.
posted by Chichikov on 1-6-2009 at 2:26 pm
YES! Finally, I got one right!
posted by Missy on 1-6-2009 at 3:39 pm
WOW! finally got one right!!!!
Yay me:)
posted by Katrina on 1-6-2009 at 5:31 pm
Love these! I always use the ’square’ system (names vertical, scores horizontal) and eliminate possibilities as I read each clue.
posted by Dawn on 1-6-2009 at 8:08 pm