There’s something intriguing about watching someone answer a question, or spin a wheel, or pick a suitcase. That’s why game shows have been around for nearly three-quarters of a century. Here are some of our favorite stories from game show lore.
The first game show ever broadcast was Spelling Bee, a BBC program that premiered on May 14, 1938. Host Freddie Grisewood dressed as a schoolteacher and asked guests to spell words. Advertisers flocked to support the program, but it received terrible reviews, as Spelling Bee was widely regarded as the most boring show on television. As Independent columnist Thomas Sutcliffe said in 2000, “One of the few happy consequences of the Second World War [was] that it took Spelling Bee off air, making the world safe for more sophisticated entertainment.”

Truth or Consequences was the first TV game show in the United States, airing as a one-time experiment in 1941. But the show did not appear again until 1950, when television had caught on commercially. The CBS Television Quiz was the first television game show to be broadcast regularly. It premiered on July 2, 1941, and ran until July 1, 1942.
You probably know about the quiz show scandals of the 1950s, but not every winner had the answers before showtime. One of the biggest legitimate winners of that era was a young psychology professor from Columbia named Dr. Joyce Brothers.
She had given up teaching to raise her newborn daughter, and in an effort to supplement the family income, Joyce applied to be a contestant on The $64,000 Question. She chose boxing as her field of expertise, and by memorizing sources that included a boxing encyclopedia, Joyce Brothers became the only woman to win the top prize.
Two years later, she appeared on the spin-off, The $64,000 Challenge, where experts were brought in to quiz contestants in their selected field. Brothers’ knowledge of the sweet science was too much for the seven boxing experts; she answered each question correctly, bringing her total earnings to $134,000.
Why does Jeopardy! require contestants to give their answers in the form of a question? Well, according to show producer Merv Griffin, the idea came from his wife Julann. Merv was brainstorming ideas for new game shows, and his wife mentioned that there hadn’t been a successful Q&A game since the quiz show scandals. Julann suggested Merv switch things up a bit, giving the answers to the contestants and letting them come up with the questions. Merv loved the idea, and so did NBC.

When Let’s Make a Deal began, studio audience members wore their regular clothing. A few weeks into the series, someone brought a sign to get Monty Hall’s attention. The sign read, “Roses are Red, Violets are Blue, I came here to deal with you.” It worked, as Monty chose the player to be a contestant. As time went on, more people brought signs, and later wacky hats. The costumes and signs became a part of the show and got crazier and crazier as the years went on.
I think it’s safe to say that host Chuck Barris did not take NBC’s cancellation of The Gong Show well. On the final episode, Barris appeared as a contestant, singing Johnny Paycheck’s “Take This Job and Shove It,” and he even gave the camera the finger. (NBC censored the gesture.)
During its very long run, The Dating Game had many celebrities compete to be selected to go on an all-expenses-paid date. These celebrities included Steve Martin, Suzanne Somers and Ron Howard. But there were some unique celebrity daters as well. Also appearing on the show were Paul Reubens (as Pee Wee Herman), Murray Langston (as The Unknown Comic), Groucho Marx, and on the 1972 Christmas show, H.R. PufnStuf made an appearance. But I’m very sorry to report that I don’t know if he won the date.
Using the pause button on his VCR, a man named Michael Larson discovered that the “random patterns” on the Press Your Luck game board were not random at all, and he was actually able to memorize the sequences. When he was on the show, he used this information to stop the board exactly where he wanted. On the single game Michael appeared, he played 35 consecutive times without hitting a Whammy, and ended up earning over $110,000 in cash and prizes. When CBS investigated, they decided that figuring out the patterns was not cheating and let him keep his winnings.
You may know that John Carpenter was the first contestant to win the million dollar jackpot on Who Wants To Be a Millionaire? But do you know the name of the first contestant who was booed by the audience? As it turns out, it was the same contestant. This happened when Regis introduced Carpenter and mentioned his employer – the IRS. And to make things worse, he worked as a collections agent.
On an episode of The Price is Right that aired December 16, 2008, a perfect Showcase bid occurred for only the second time in the show’s history. But it was the first time since the Double Showcase Rule went into effect, so the contestant won both showcases. When it happened, the show’s producers and host Drew Carey were suspicious of the activities of certain audience members during the bidding. Because of this, there was a 45-minute delay between the showcase presentation and actual reveal. In interviews, the lucky (or very skilled) contestant Terry Kniess stated he did not cheat, but was a studious viewer who had watched the show closely for years.
Re: number 8
The best moment about John Carpenter winning Millionaire was when he called his father on a lifeline and then preceded to tell him (along with Regis and the audience) that he didn’t need his help but just wanted him to know he was about to win the million dollars. The game show variation of pointing to the outfield and calling your shot…
posted by Tom in GA on 7-13-2009 at 10:33 pm
One of the craziest moments on The Dating Game was the woman who answered, “In the butt?” when asked where her husband’s favorite place to have sex was.
posted by K8 on 7-13-2009 at 10:43 pm
@ k8
That was on the newlywed show, I remember bob eubanks looking like he was gonna wet himself when it happened…very funny in any case.
posted by dennis on 7-13-2009 at 11:16 pm
how can you not include ken jennings 75 consecutive day (74 winning days) run on jeopardy?! that happened almost nine years ago, and anyone has yet to even come close to that record!
posted by Michele on 7-13-2009 at 11:27 pm
I remember when the perfect show case happened and wondering why Drew Carey looked more like his dog died than being excited. Guess he thought it was a cheat.
posted by Cory on 7-14-2009 at 3:26 am
Tom Selleck was also on The Dating Game as a contestant before he was famous.
20 years ago I got picked out of the audience on the “New” Let’s Make A Deal which was filmed @ MGM studios in Orlando. I picked what was behind door #2 which was a big chicken coop (cue loser music)but I did get a plastic 35mm camera for a consolation prize about 3 months later.
posted by AL in NC on 7-14-2009 at 5:13 am
To be honest, I hate game shows, but I do enjoy Jeopardy. My favorite moment was when there was a three way tie. I’ve seen two contestants tie, but never all three.
posted by Carol on 7-14-2009 at 5:58 am
@ dennis – That moment never made it to air on The Newlywed Game, it was edited out. Bob Eubanks forgot all about that moment until he saw it on a retrospective of game show moments.
@ Carol – there was once a three-way tie on Jeopardy, it was fairly recent.
A great game show moment that never aired was the biggest winner of all time on any version of Password (until the recent Million Dollar Password). A man won well over $100,000 during a long winning streak. I remember him well because he was injured just before taping the shows and had a cast on his arm.
When he came to collect his check, he was arrested as a wanted fugitive! The cast on his arm was there to cover up an identifying tattoo!
posted by Wayne on 7-14-2009 at 7:41 am
On June 13, 2000, both the Final Jeopardy answer and the million dollar question on “Who Wants to Be a Millionnaire” were about Isaac Newton’s career as an alchemist.
posted by steven on 7-14-2009 at 8:06 am
Just to clarify — Groucho Marx was on \The Dating Game\, but not as a contestant himself. He was on a special Fathers’ Day episode in 1967 where he was asking questions to three bachelors on behalf of his daughter Melinda.
posted by wboenig on 7-14-2009 at 8:58 am
H.R. PufnStuf is NOT a Muppet(tm).
posted by airship on 7-14-2009 at 10:38 am
I remember a young Farrah Fawcett on the dating game….
posted by Zane on 7-14-2009 at 11:03 am
I always liked that clip from Catchphrase where it looks like the cartoon is whacking off.
posted by Lisa on 7-14-2009 at 11:40 am
I remember Kirstie Alley as a contestant on the $25,000 Pyramid, and Vanna White as a contestant on The Price is Right. (I saw them on an old game show retrospective years ago).
posted by Steve on 7-14-2009 at 11:42 am
Oh yeah, and no mention of Michael Jackson (during the Jackson 5 years) on The Dating Game?
posted by Steve on 7-14-2009 at 11:44 am
“Advertisers flocked to support the program…”
…on the BBC?
posted by Tom on 7-14-2009 at 11:50 am
My friend actually wrote a book on gameshows and their hosts. He interviewed them a got a lot of back stories.
http://www.amazon.com/Television-Game-Show-Hosts-Biographies/dp/0786445734/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1247586585&sr=8-1
I can shoot you his email addy if you like.
posted by Andy on 7-14-2009 at 11:51 am
When Michael Larson was on Press Your Luck, CBS actually tried to not pay him, but their lawyers later determined that he hadn’t “cheated,” but merely figured out how best to play the game. They quickly revamped the board to make it much more difficult (but still not impossible) to do Larson’s feat again.
I watched the special on GSN that was made shortly before Peter Tomarken was killed. Fascinating.
posted by Dave on 7-14-2009 at 1:13 pm
@k8 – that was the Newlywed Game
posted by PartiallyDeflected on 7-14-2009 at 1:37 pm
Wait a sec – Kirstie Alley was a contestant on the $25,000 pyramid? I distinctly remember her as a contestant on Match Game…before she fixed the gap between her two front teeth.
I wonder if she’s been on any others…
posted by Karyn on 7-14-2009 at 4:21 pm
Ummm…The Biggest Loser?
(ouch)
posted by Richard Dixon on 7-14-2009 at 5:51 pm