Stacy Conradt
The Quick 10: 10 Miss Universe Controversies
by Stacy Conradt - August 27, 2009 - 4:15 PM

q10

If you follow these things, and maybe even if you don’t, you know that the Miss Universe pageant was last weekend. Miss Venezuela took the crown for the second year in the row. All in all it was a pretty tame competition, but it isn’t always that way – the pageant has certainly seen its share of controversy over the years. Here are 10 of them.

armi1. The very first winner, Armi Kuusela of Finland, was just 17 when she took home the title in 1952. She was about 10 months into her year-long reign when she decided to hand over her sash and crown because she was getting married immediately and would no longer meet the requirements. Why she couldn’t wait two months is anyone’s guess. She was the first beauty queen to voluntarily give up a position, and perhaps lacking protocol, pageant organizers let her keep her title.
2. During the pageant of 1969, Miss Austria Eva von Rueber-Staier upset quite a few people with her response to one particular question on a written questionnaire. When asked to name the greatest historical figure in the world, she had responded with “Mao Tse-tung.” Although this obviously didn’t sit well with everyone, she still advanced to the semi-finals before being edged out. She did, however, take the Miss World title the same year. You might know her better as General Gogol’s beautiful assistant in the James Bond movies The Spy Who Loved Me, For Your Eyes Only and Octopussy.

3. Miss Philippines Margarita Moran sort of made the same mistake after the 1973 pageant, though probably not as extreme. She won the competition and then proclaimed Richard Nixon as the “Greatest man on Earth.” This was right in the middle of Watergate, mind you. Nixon sent her a thank you note, expressing his gratitude on her “thoughtful comment on my efforts to bring peace in the world.”

4. It wasn’t a contestant who created a stir in 1974, it was the host country – or rather, the host country’s hostess. A former beauty queen herself, Imelda Marcos understandably wanted to show off the Philippines when it was chosen to host the Miss Universe pageant. But perhaps she went a little too far. She immediately ordered a 10,000-seat amphitheater to be built in under three months, using millions of dollars when much of the nation’s population needed aid. And to top it off, after the parade route was set, she had some of the shabbier homes on the route bulldozed, hidden by fences or otherwise concealed so the contestants from other countries would only see the best side of Manila.

5. And that wasn’t the only controversy to strike in 1974. The winner, Ampara Muñoz of Spain, pulled a Miss Finland and willfully gave up her crown. The runner-up, Miss Wales, would have been offered the crown, but she had recently been named Miss World and couldn’t carry both titles. And, actually, Miss Wales ended up having to relinquish her Miss World title anyway when it was discovered that she was an unwed mother (gasp). Apparently the pageant officials gave up at that point, because they didn’t even bother offering the crown to the second runner up – Miss Finland.

6. Everyone’s favorite game show host was the culprit behind the 1987 brouhaha. Maybe not everyone’s favorite game show host – I guess maybe some people prefer Alex Trebek or Pat Sajak. I digress. Pageant host and animal activist Bob Barker requested that the pageant stop offering fur coats and other prizes related to animal cruelty as rewards to the winner and runners-up. They refused, and the 20-year Miss Universe veteran stepped down. The 1987 pageant in Singapore was his last.

alicia7. You might remember this one – the 1996 winner, Venezuelan Alicia Machado, was basically warned that she was getting too fat to keep her crown. Officials threatened to replace her with the runner up, Miss Aruba, unless she trimmed down. She did, but it certainly didn’t help matters when Donald Trump went on Howard Stern and referred to Machado as “an eating machine.”
8. In 1999, it was revealed that Miss Guam was pregnant. She was disqualified, and pageant officials thought it would be a great opportunity to stump the remaining contestants with a tricky question: If a Miss Universe becomes pregnant, should she be allowed to continue her reign and keep the title? Most contestants awkwardly stumbled their way through the question, but Miss Botswana was prepared and answered that there was no way Miss Universe was any less spectacular with a bun in the oven, and that she should not only keep the crown, but celebrate her femininity. She won the title.

9. In 1966, several contestants from Latin American countries bonded together to have a press conference to share their opinion that they were considered the “nothings” of the pageant and that European girls were preferred. Misses Argentina, Brazil, Ecuador, Paraguay and Venezuela were sort of proved right a few days later when Miss Sweden won, but overall they have been incorrect: Venezuela ranks second when it comes to how often they land in the semi-finals, Colombia had first runner up placements three years in a row, and Puerto Rico and Venezuela are the only two countries to have winners in each of the last four decades.

10. The 1979 pageant held in Perth, Australia, had only just finished when a huge crash and loud screams filled the building. Part of the hastily-constructed stage had collapsed, injuring 20 candidates and lots of reporters and photographers.

Do you follow the pageants at all? Any opinion on last weekend’s events? I can’t say that I follow them too much, so fill me in if I missed anything good.

Click here to get a Risk-Free issue of mental_floss magazine
Comments (12)
  1. Evidently there IS a bit of a kerfuffle this year. There’s some sort of argument going on over the costume that Miss Peru wore in the opening sequence…Bolivia is claiming that the dress is based on their cultural traditions and that it isn’t Peruvian in origin. I just think it was great that she didn’t topple over while wearing it, since the headgear is enormous!

  2. Isn’t there always some problem with someone’s costume. In 2007 there was a big uproar about Miss Mexico’s costume which depicted the Cristero War complete with bullet-studded belt and Crucifix necklace.

  3. I was positive Miss Australia was going to win, and was shocked when she got 3rd runner up!

  4. I have to say that to me Venezuela has the most beautiful women in the world. I remember watching a Miss Venezuela pageant on telemundo years ago and thinking that any one of them could have passed as Miss Universe. So it’s no surprise to me that they won the last two or that they seem to be one of the finalists nearly every year.

  5. My mom used to tell me a story about the workers who died building Imelda Marcos’ amphitheater. They said there wasn’t enough time for the cement to harden, but she insisted they finish it. According to legend parts of it collapsed, killing several workers. The ghosts of the men visited the people who made them keep working. I’m not sure if that’s true, but it’s definitely scary. (And I wouldn’t put it past Imelda either…)

  6. When the building collapsed in Manila, Imelda Marcos ordered that the workers build on top of them because of the rush. Public outcry was so great that she had to relent and take the bodies out.

  7. Growing up, my family would always watch the Miss America pageant. Each member of the family would “pick” their favorite and then we would see if the judges agreed with us. Nowadays, we don’t follow it anymore. They keep switching channels and dates, so it is no longer an appointment show for us. Also it seems to me that they do far more behind the scenes, so you really only get to see the finalists in any real way. I also can’t stand the whole feminist slant to the pageants now. It is not about “beauty” anymore. No, rather it is about scholarships and being a representative of womenkind and ‘making a difference in the world’. By trying to make the contest more important and have more meaning, they have destroyed the original focus of the contest. Put the beauty back in the beauty contest, please.

  8. I don’t watch or keep up with any of the beauty pageants. But this was an interesting article, though I really wish the pictures had captions because I have no idea which one the lady in the red dress is…

  9. I agree with Fran, I am often lost on some of the pictures you guys put up because of the lack of captions. Sometimes there is a note saying pictured right or below, etc. But an actual caption would be most helpful.

  10. Brit.

    Alicia from the properties of the picture. She’s the Venz.

  11. I love that my homeland, Guam, is mentioned…no matter what the context!

  12. You missed one big controversy!

    In 2002, Oxana Fedorova of Russia won Miss Universe but five months later, she was dethroned for failing to fulfill her obligations. Fedorova claimed that she hadn’t expected to win and that her duties as Miss Universe conflicted with her desire to complete her doctoral program. The Miss Universe Organization stated that Fedorova was being difficult; she had told MUO that she had to prolong her stay in Russia because of her “sick grandmother,” when in fact she did not have a sick grandmother to attend to. This was the first time in the history of the pageant that a title holder was dethroned. Fedorova was replaced by her first runner-up, Justine Pasek of Panama.

    http://www.criticalbeauty.com

Comment

commenting policy