I know we have some Lost fans out there – what did you think of the season premiere? It so happens that yesterday was also the day Alexander Selkirk was rescued in 1709 – if you’re not familiar, Selkirk is the man thought to have inspired Robinson Crusoe. Who knew Groundhog Day was such a momentous occasion for people deserted on islands? Between Lost and Selkirk, I was inspired to learn more about other famous castaways (of the non-Gilligan variety). Here’s what I found out.
1. Alexander Selkirk. We’ll start with the original. In October 1704, Selkirk was serving as a sailing master on the St. George. When the ship stopped at the archipelago of Juan Fernandez, Selkirk tried to convince most of the crew to stay on the island with him, saying that the ship was not seaworthy and the captain wasn’t leading well. In the end, he was the only one who stayed on the island, and he figured that another ship would be along soon enough and he would catch a ride with them. He figured wrong: it would be nearly four and a half years before a friendly ship crossed his path (two Spanish ships showed up before then, but he didn’t trust them). In the meantime, he fended for himself just fine, eating feral goats, wild turnips and black pepper berries. He even built a couple of huts for shelter. These days, the island he lived on has been renamed Robinson Crusoe, and a nearby island that he likely never set foot upon has been christened Alexander Selkirk.
2. Leendert Hasenbosch. Unlike our first two castaways, Hasenbosch was not so successful as a castaway. This Dutchman was abandoned on Ascension Island in the South Atlantic in 1725 as punishment for sodomy. His crew didn’t just leave him for dead, though – a diary left behind by the man indicated that he began his stay with a tent, seeds, a month’s worth of water, books, writing materials and even extra clothes. The problem? The island apparently had no fresh water source. After his month’s supply ran out, Hasenbosch took to drinking turtle blood and his own urine to try to stay hydrated. He likely died after about six months; British sailors discovered his abandoned tent and diary in January, 1726. Hasenbosch didn’t need to die, though: there are actually two sources of fresh water on the island, one of which actually allowed the entire crew of the HMS Roebuck to survive a shipwreck for two months in the early 1700s.
3. Marguerite de La Rocque. Marguerite was sailing to the New World with a relative in 1542 – the exact nature of this relative is unknown, with varying sources claiming it was her brother, cousin or uncle – and began sleeping with a man on the ship. Her brother/uncle/cousin was displeased and turned them both out on the “Isle of Demons.” It’s said that he would have financially benefited from her death, so perhaps her relative’s reasoning wasn’t all about morality. Marguerite’s maid-servant was also dumped on the island. We aren’t exactly sure how long Marguerite was on the island, but it was long enough to get pregnant and have the baby, then watch the baby die from malnutrition. Her lover and her maid-servant also died, leaving Marguerite to hunt wild game to stay alive – yeah, Kate Austen’s got nothing on this chick. Eventually, a group of fishermen found Marguerite and brought her back, where she relayed her captivating tale to the Queen of Navarre, which is how we know about it today. Historians are fairly sure that the “Isle of Demons” is the one we know today as Hospital or Harrington Island; Marguerite’s Cave is a popular attraction on the island these days.
4. Ada Blackjack. You think being stranded on a tropical island is tough? Try being stranded in Siberia. That’s what happened to Inuit Ada Blackjack in 1921. She accompanied a group of men who were sent to claim Siberia’s Wrangel Island for Canada; Ada was meant to be their cook and seamstress. Things went bad quickly – rations ran out, hunting was terrible and one man was deathly ill – and in January 1923, three of the four men left to trek across the frozen sea back to the mainland to try to get help, leaving Ada and the ailing explorer, Lorne Knight, on the island. They were only gone for a couple of months when Knight died of scurvy, leaving Ada to fend for herself. And she did. For five months, Ada survived with nothing but a cat for companionship. She was rescued in August, 1923, and the three men who took out across the ice nine months earlier were never heard from again.
5. Narcisse Pelletier. I’m not sure I have the skills it would take to last on a desert island now, as an adult, let alone as a teenager. But Narcisse Pelletier did. He was only 14 when the ship he was serving on struck a reef in Papua New Guinea in 1858. When some of the crew members tried to get to nearby Rossel Island for water and supplies, they were attacked by its inhabitants. The crew members who managed to survive the attack jumped in a long boat and paddled the heck out of there. Almost two weeks later, the crew made it to an island, where they found fresh water to quench their thirst. Apparently wanting one less mouth to feed, the crew abandoned Pelletier on the island where three Aboriginal women found him. They ended up adopting him, giving him the new name “Amglo.”
6. Otokichi. It’s too bad Otokichi and Narcisse Pelletier never met, because they surely would have had a lot to talk about. Otokichi was also 14 when the rice transport ship he was on blew off course in 1832. It drifted for 14 months while the crew slowly ate away at their cargo. By the time the ship drifted ashore on Washington’s Olympic Peninsula, only three of the 14 original crew members were still alive, including Otokichi. The men were found by the Makah Indian tribe and were enslaved before being handed over to the Hudson Bay Company.
7. Poon Lim. Here’s a comparatively recent castaway – Poon Lim’s tenure on a raft afloat in the South Atlantic occurred during WWII. He was working as a steward on a British ship that was torpedoed 750 miles east of the Amazon. As the ship exploded, Lim grabbed a life jacket and jumped off, making him the only survivor of his 54-man crew. As luck would have it, he floated for a couple of hours and then found a life raft that had floated away from the wreckage. It contained 40 liters of water, a small amount of food, flare guns and a few other supplies. For 133 days, Lim managed to stay alive by fishing from the raft. He was spotted by U.S. Navy planes and they dropped a marker buoy in the water so they could come back and rescue him, but sadly, a huge storm hit just after and Lim was lost again. Finally, on April 5, 1943, he hit land and was rescued by Brazilian fisherman.
8. Philip Ashton. After being captured by a band of pirates in 1722, this sailor escaped their clutches and hid in the jungle of Roatan Island in the Bay Islands of Honduras until they gave up looking for him and sailed on. For a while, Ashton’s diet consisted of nothing but fruit, because he had escaped his captors with nothing but the clothes on his back. He had no weapons to kill animals with and apparently was unable to devise a way to fish. Lucky for him, he happened across another castaway. They were great friends for three days, until the unnamed man went out for food and never came back. He did, however, leave behind a great stash of gunpowder, knives and tobacco, which allowed Ashton to start killing tortoises and cooking them. He was rescued by a ship from New England shortly thereafter. Sound made up? You’re not the only one who thinks so. When Ashton published his memoirs after getting back to the U.S. in 1725, everyone thought they were fiction – Robinson Crusoe had only been on bookshelves for a few years and everyone thought this was a similar adventure story.
9. Charles Barnard. In 1812, Barnard’s ship rescued a British ship called Isabella, which had been wrecked off Eagle Island, part of the Falklands. While they were docked at Eagle Island, Barnard and a few of his crew decided that they would need more provisions since they were picking up this shipwrecked crew and went ashore to gather some things. Not ones to show gratitude, the crew of the Isabella took over Barnard’s ship while he was out and left their rescuers to fend for themselves on Eagle Island. Luckily, they were rescued 18 months later.
10. Tom Neale. There are all of these people who were stranded on islands or boats and wanted nothing more than to get to civilization again, and then there’s Tom Neale. Neale desperately wanted an island all to himself, and in October 1952, he got his chance. A boat passing by Suwarrow Island, a place uninhabited since WWII, agreed to drop him off there, along with two cats and as many supplies as he could carry. The people who had lived there before WWII had left behind chickens and pigs, so he ate the pigs and domesticated the chickens, planted a garden, built a hut and lived his happy island life. That is, until May of 1954, when he threw his back out. At least, he thought he did. He hitched a ride to Rarotonga, another one of the Cook Islands, and went to a hospital, where he was told it was just arthritis. He returned to Suwarrow in 1960 and lived similarly for another four years. His third and final stay on the island lasted from 1967 to 1977, when a yacht stopped at the island and found Neale quite ill. They took him to Rarotonga, where Neale discovered he had stomach cancer. He died eight months later.
Do you know of any others? And, more importantly, what did you think of Lost? I know there are some pretty strong opinions out there, both for and against – let us know which side you’re on.
Often I wish I could leave it all and go live on an uninhabited island like Tom Neale. Or even something similar to the setting of ‘The Beach’.
posted by Anthony on 2-3-2010 at 5:51 pm
Stacy,
I am one of the LOSTies, though I came into it *after* Season 1 aired (da** my brother for bringing that DVD home over the winter holidays and getting me hooked).
Last night’s final (arrgh) season opener was especially WTF for me, but I LOVED it.
posted by Amy on 2-3-2010 at 6:00 pm
Oh, and forgot… I am on BEN’s side whatever that may be. I actually preferred his Bad A$$ side, but it seems Faux Locke matches and bests that!
posted by Amy on 2-3-2010 at 6:03 pm
I’ve developed a LOST addiction over the last couple of years. New Locke bothers me, there’s something not real about him…which is not to say I’m a Ben fan. No one likes a puppeteer. I just can’t wait until they start answering some old questions and stop asking new ones!
posted by sammylee on 2-3-2010 at 7:13 pm
I remember watching the premiere episode (it aired back-to-back with Desperate Housewives) way back when, and recognized it for what it was – a high-end soap opera.
Sorry Matthew Fox, but you weren’t sute enough to hook me. Two episodes later, I gave up.
posted by Michael on 2-3-2010 at 7:19 pm
@Amy
No wonder you like Ben, you came in after season 1. If you had seen it from the start, you’d know he’s been responsible for all the stuff the Lostaways have been thru.
I liked it, I was nervous they’d painted themselves into a corner by setting of a nuke to end last season.
Anyone else think Selkirk got screwed by having the island he lived on named for fictional Crusoe, while he gets the other, smaller island? There was a History Channel program (hr, maybe 2) about “The Real Robinson Crusoe” that was good. Apparently being alone w/ only feral goats to talk to for 4 yrs can make you a little nutty.
ReCaptcha – not betrayed
posted by Big Jonny on 2-3-2010 at 7:25 pm
When I was a kid, I read \Island of the Blue Dolphins\ by Scott O’dell. It’s based on a true story also…
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Island_of_the_Blue_Dolphins
posted by Ariane on 2-3-2010 at 7:30 pm
OMG Ariane I read that too! And the whole time i was reading this I was trying to figure out what it was called. Gosh, what a story!
posted by tess on 2-3-2010 at 8:23 pm
@ Big Jonny -
Actually, I watched Season 1 after initially AIRED but before Season 2 started…
but I still love Ben!
posted by Anon Emous on 2-3-2010 at 9:19 pm
I don’t watch Lost, but Sawyer (the character, not the actor) is from my hometown.
I have seen a half-dozen or so episodes, and I don’t get it.
ReC: But managing…
posted by Beau on 2-4-2010 at 12:15 am
Life of Pi…
posted by Mommy de Bean on 2-4-2010 at 12:21 am
I have a theory for Lost.
In the recap episode there was a scene with Jacob and some other darker guy (black hair, grey shirt..ect) that i call Dark Guy. In the scene Jacob and Dark Guy are arguing and Dark Guy says he wants to kill Jacob. But he cant untill he finds a loophole.
Before Ben and Locke Twin kill Jacob he tells Locke Twin “I see you found your loophole” then Ben proceeds to kill him. In the actual episode the smoke monster (who is DARK!) comes then Locke Twin says “Im sorry you had to see me like that”
Sooo….. Locke Twin is actually Dark Guy who turns into the smoke monster.
Just a theory.
posted by ufluffed on 2-4-2010 at 12:51 am
Not really sure if this qualifies as a castaway or not, but there was a Japanese soldier (I believe his name was Hiroo Onado) who was told to hide out in the South Pacific jungle until his superiors came back for him. Japan surrendered in 1945 but Onado was still out there. Several attempts were made to convince him the war was over, but he absolutely refused to believe Japan would surrender and would not come out. He stayed hidden for about 30 years.
posted by Pete on 2-4-2010 at 8:39 am
correction: It’s Hiroo ONODA, not Onado.
posted by Pete on 2-4-2010 at 8:50 am
For Leendert Hasenbosch, you start by saying, “Unlike our first two castaways…” However, Hesenbosch is number 2 on your list. Those numbers don’t quite add up.
posted by Steven on 2-4-2010 at 9:24 am
“The problem? The island apparently had no fresh water source. After his month’s supply ran out, Hasenbosch took to drinking turtle blood and his own urine to try to stay hydrated. He likely died after about six months; ”
I honestly get the image of this guy with his tent/seeds/water/diary on one little part of the island freaking out b/c he’s going to die, while there’s a fresh water waterfall less than 100 meters away from him…kinda the image of Michael Scott in the “Survivor Man” episode of The Office…
not funny b/c somebody did suffer and die, but I still like my image…
posted by OkieMelissa on 2-4-2010 at 10:12 am
@Steven: I believe she meant Selkirk and Crusoe as the “first two castaways”.
posted by AAAKnight on 2-4-2010 at 10:44 am
@ufluffed Yeah, whatever has taken over Locke is definitely the smoke monster. We’ve taken to calling what you call Locke Twin “Evil Jacob” or “Anti-Jacob.” I’m not sure that this qualifies as a theory, since Evil Jacob (in Locke’s body–or sort of body) definitely admits to being the smoke monster. It also appears that the real Jacob is tied to the island’s power–after he was killed the magical spring in the temple went brown and didn’t (?) work.
I also find it very odd that the contingency of Others (who I’m now not sure are linked to the new people at the temple led by the Japanese guy)led by Richard didn’t seem to be affected by the bomb or the “reset.”
The irritating thing is that the more I watch this show, the less I understand it. I’ve been watching since the first episode and I feel like I understand it less now than I did then. At the beginning, the big mysteries were “What is that smoke thing?” (which appears to now have been answered–but not in a very satisfying way) and “Why on earth is there a polar bear on a tropical island?” (which has been answered–but the newer mysteries are even stranger and more convoluted).
So to answer the “What did you think of Lost” question…um….well, one episode was not enough to answer that :). I don’t think I like the new parallel (or alternate…not sure what the best word for this thing is) reality in which the plane didn’t crash and the island is underwater. I don’t need more confusion about who is doing what or why! I would also very much like to know if that reality is working alongside current reality or if it’s just a totally different thing…like a “What if?” I guess my theory there is that all of the people who are destined to be on the island will somehow end up there in this new reality that has been created…but I’m not sure how that’s going to happen with the underwater island (and how did that happen, anyway?).
I need more friends who watch this show so I won’t have to rant about it at great length in Mental_Floss comments :)
posted by Fruppi on 2-4-2010 at 12:22 pm
Oh, and two side notes before I go and get some actual work done–I love how the writers incorporate fan terminology–like “The Others” (I love when Juliette or Ben refer to themselves as “an Other”), tailies (and isn’t it nice to see a few of them again? Like the children?), and smoke monster. The other side note is how happy I am to have Charlie back–even if he’s junkie Charlie again and not the clean and sober Charlie we came to know and love.
posted by Fruppi on 2-4-2010 at 12:25 pm
“All Brave Sailors” is a novelization of the true story of seven men stranded on a liferaft after their freighter was sunk and all survivors executed by a Nazi sneak attack. Not all made it to land: several died from their initial wounds, and others voluntarily left the raft to drift away at sea… Quite a book.
posted by Chicago ExPat on 2-4-2010 at 1:28 pm
So what happened to the guys who left Selkirk did they make it back?
posted by Brit on 2-4-2010 at 3:33 pm
Eddie Rickenbacher, US WW I ace was adrift in the Pacific for 25 days after a plane crash. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eddie_Rickenbacker
Seven Came Through is the book he wrote of that experience. Great reading! Although it has been about 30 years since I read it.
posted by Rick on 2-5-2010 at 8:41 pm
JFK
posted by BenGipsat on 2-7-2010 at 7:20 pm