Where Knowledge Junkies Get Their Fix
McAfee Secure sites help keep you safe from identity theft, credit card fraud, spyware, spam, viruses and online scams
Jason English
Spare Change
by Jason English - June 13, 2007 - 11:24 AM

sparechange.jpgHere’s something random for you. I’ve been tossing my change into this old pretzel container for years. On Saturday, I will head to the bank for the official counting. Anyone care to venture a guess?

There should be some incentive. Mangesh, do we have any prizes back there? The person who comes closest without going over will possibly win something.*

*But not the money in the jar. I worked too hard for that. Maybe next time we’ll hold a “Guess My Weight” contest.

———–> Mangesh’s response: “Sure, why not! Let’s give out a mental_floss T-shirt to the winner, and a Law School in a Box to the second place.”

———–> Update: I’ve posted additional photos of the jar alongside other objects, for perspective. See those photos here.

———–> One More Update: The coins have been counted and the winning bidders will be announced Monday morning. We’re now closing the comments. Thanks for playing!

Comments (317)
  1. I guess $85.37.

  2. $80!!

  3. 100$

  4. $242.00

  5. $73.68

  6. $157.78

  7. $277.32

  8. One dollar, Bob.

  9. $302.00

  10. 137.88

  11. $184.00

  12. $120, watch out for silver and Bicentennial quarters, don’t let the bank keep those! Silver quarters (pre 1965) don’t show the copper guts when you look at the sides and Bicentennial (which have a higher but not 100% silver content), well, I’m sure you can spot those on your own…

  13. $32.91
    I would prefer my winnings to be in chocolate form.

  14. $56.73

  15. $10.00

  16. $92.50

  17. $142.36

    If it comes out to $142.35 I’m going to be upset.

  18. $312.68

  19. $221.19

  20. $23.86

  21. $180.00

  22. $47.82

  23. $38.31

  24. $101.00

  25. $35.00

  26. $123.00

  27. I’ll be bold and say $356.04.

    A service organization I’m in (Active 20-30 Club) has a program called Pennies-A-Day where we collect our spare change throughout the year. At our annual convention, we present it (in the form of a check, thank goodness) to a local charity. Last year, about 20 of our chapters wrote a combined check for over $14,000 to Cystic Fibrosis of Phoenix. It always amazes me how spare change can really add up!

  28. $62.14

  29. $412.86…I collect coinage too.

  30. $142.00

  31. $129.00

  32. I’ll say $63.00. A friend of mine has a glass water jug (the five gallon kind) and recently cleaned it out to take to the bank. A large portion of her summer vacation to Italy, Germany, and France came from that. Really is amazing how it adds up. I second the note to watch for the rare coins–especially old pennies and nickles!

    :)

  33. 271.75

    I’d really like a Scurvy T-shirt. Ladies size small. Yay! I hope I win!

    p.s. I frickin’ LOVE you!

  34. Hmmmm…how about $197.42?

  35. I see a lot of pennies in there and I’m used to being disappointed when I go for change-counting myself, so I’m guessing…

    $33.47

  36. I will say $163.28

  37. $74.03

  38. $154.54 in change, plus a small eyeglass screw, lint, and I-don’t-wanna-know-what-THAT-is!

  39. I would guess $74.18.

  40. $102.53

  41. Oh come on, you know the answer has to be $42.00

  42. Looks like about $34 worth. I think people are guessing WAY high.

  43. $75.30

  44. $64.52

  45. $87.95

  46. $123.45

  47. $35.15

  48. $134.80

  49. Gotta be 142.37!

  50. $327.23

  51. $87.68

  52. $364.99

  53. $342.13

  54. Looks like $280. I have a similar jar but my kids always take the money out for lunch money so it never gets as full as yours.

  55. $276

  56. Hmmmm, aren’t banks closed on Saturdays?

  57. 152.63

  58. Some are. Not Commerce Bank, though. Seven days a week!

  59. $127.64

  60. $67.48

  61. $27! My old roommate used to answer 27 for anything, and it was my first response…

  62. $250.90 You might want to check your pennies for wheatbacks. My kids enjoy looking for the old money.

  63. $112.42

  64. $186.44

  65. $102.33

  66. $272.59

  67. $123.45

  68. $57.57

  69. $83.47 (in currency of where Jason resides – US or ?)

  70. $75.23

  71. $212.91

  72. $98.72

  73. $26.97

  74. $91.70

  75. $182.59

  76. There is no scale in the pciture. How am I supposed to to know if it is 12 inches or 16 inches tall (or otherwise)!? I’ve never come across pretzles in a jar so I’m totally at a loss; hazarding a wild guess.

    $175.36

    (assuming that any errant foreign currecy and slugs are discarded ;) )

  77. I would gues $180.00

  78. $413

  79. Here’s my prediction: the bank teller will look at that and laugh and tell you to go home and roll it up.

  80. $138 (and change)

  81. Hmmm…$52.15?

  82. 382.59

  83. $145

  84. By the way, if I win, can I have the Law in the Box instead? Thanks

  85. $115

  86. $193.41

  87. 127.51

  88. 71.05

  89. i’m gonna say $335.62

  90. $111.11

  91. I’m guessing $94.17. I collect my spare change in old diaper wipes boxes. Over the years I’ve bought a laptop and a digital camera with my collections. Out of each bi-monthly paycheck I take $100 cash for gas money, incidental groceries. . basically walking around money. Whatever is left of that at the end of two weeks goes in the boxes and I start over. It’s an incentive to curb my impulse spending and a great way to save for things that aren’t necessarily in the budget.

  92. $389.29

  93. $68.22

    (that’s my standard answer for everything, too!)

  94. $142.42, the perfect number

  95. $218.50

  96. $167.05

  97. I’ll guess $68.35…and let me know if they accept it without you rolling it first!

  98. $75.75

  99. $192.92

  100. 92.18

  101. $117.13

  102. $117.00

  103. $134.20

  104. 287.53

  105. Scratch out my first guess, please! My final answer is $134.20. (dang technologicamall things!!)

  106. $42.67…plus change (just kidding)

  107. $263.17
    unless you have to sort out the Canadian quarters :-)

  108. 123.46 It would be wacky if that’s really what it is

  109. $350.00

  110. $102.77

  111. 28.32

  112. Is the picture exactly what you are taking to the bank? Or have you managed to fill the jar up to the top?

    If you are taking the jar as is, about halfway full, I say… $59

    If it’s full, I say… $140

  113. $452.78 – and not a penny more! ;)

  114. Ummm…

    $67.63

  115. Oh…let’s say $53.82

  116. $70.

  117. 114.37

  118. 64.84

  119. Wisdom of Crowds tells me it is $145.01

  120. Wisdom of Crowds says $145.01

  121. I will guess $129.42 (hope it is more for your sake!)

  122. I wish I knew the volume of the jar… looks like a lot of silver in there…

    My guess is $370.00.

  123. $325

  124. $18.13

  125. 314.15
    —-
    anyone want a bit o the pi

  126. $88

    (oooh, law school in a box, oh please!)

  127. $24.42

  128. $10

  129. Hey is that an Utz pretzel container?

    $87.50

  130. $116.79

  131. i’ll say $123.21.

  132. I will guess $49.00

  133. $42.50

  134. 15.1415926535897932384626433

  135. $47.50

  136. $128.21

  137. $27.75

  138. $348.14

  139. $249

  140. $74.28

  141. Looks like everybody wants to venture a guess…
    $45.73

  142. $123.45

  143. $1, Bob.

  144. $110

  145. 43.87

  146. Why not: $81.01

  147. $63.50 unless of course you calculate the post 74 nickels and pennies at their melt value, in which case the total would be 91.80.

  148. $108 big money, big money, no wammies

  149. 48.29

  150. Years? $68.68

  151. $400!

  152. $390

  153. $390

  154. $90

  155. $123.42

  156. $78

  157. $93.22

  158. $412.01, call it a hunch…a bad hunch…hehe
    (I never win at anything, and so I am sure to be wrong, thus the “bad hunch!”)

  159. I’m going to say $223.82

  160. Im thinking $125.14 but for your sake, I hope its more. Good luck!

  161. $875.

  162. $42.36

  163. $371.59

  164. $72.37

  165. I saw a guy unload a 5-gallon water jug into a coinstar machine. I’m not going to disclose the amount (lest there be someone who’s a more accurate guesser than I).. but my guess, assuming the jar was full:

    $575.

  166. $124.83

    And a paperclip or two.

  167. $76.53

  168. $56.92

  169. Lessee…Just throwing a random number out there…How about $73.31?

  170. Clearly, $19.28

  171. $137.59

  172. 198.60

    Suppose to be a lucky year for the ones born 1986.

  173. 238.73

  174. $188.19

  175. Here I go: $158.24. I am very curious.

  176. 172.56

  177. $136.37

  178. 93.74

    seems random enough to have a chance

  179. $56

  180. I had to laugh …. when’s the last time you got 176 responses to something? Yes, we come to the website because we love trivia and are a little nerdy (OK, maybe I should just speak for myself), but offer us a free T-shirt and we go nuts. It’s like those crazy women at one of those day-after-Christmas sales. I’ll guess $64, with no rhyme or reason why, it’s just the number that popped into my head. By the way, will you ever offer that Pavlov T-S in another color?

  181. $144

  182. $69.60

  183. $38.22 It’s just too easy

  184. $222.22

  185. $157.73 (USD)

  186. $74.82

  187. Might as well join the party: $117.71

  188. $97.82

  189. $189.42

  190. $150.00

  191. $195.15

  192. I’ll go with $84.39 (But the optimist in me disagrees, saying that it will most likely be more) congrats for being able to save your money!

  193. $46.49

  194. Rahhh, i have to read through 192 comments to make sure no one has the same number as me!
    Anyways, i say around $124.27 :)

  195. Yeah, i had a similar looking size of jar of coins, in GB pounds though, and it came to 74 quid, seemed like free money :)

  196. $98.40

  197. 88.88

  198. $88.88

  199. 172.73

  200. Just for laughs
    $78.22
    Send the box and t-shirt please

  201. $222.23

  202. $247.00 – Love you all!

  203. 187.76

  204. how about $193.54?

  205. if that’s all you’ve collected after years of saving, that’s kind of sad.

    my guess: $69.97

  206. 45.00

  207. ehh again is the picture how much is in there or did it get filled?
    Because I’m not overly original I’ll say $100 at the level it looks like there and $250 if its full – and that is my estimate of the full value, not the value minus whatever percent the bank takes for counting it (at mine, yes even if you are a member)

  208. I had no idea how badly people wanted a t-shirt or law-degree substitute.

    Couple of clarifications:

    1) What you see is what you’re guessing. I will take that jar, exactly as it looks in the photo, to the bank on Saturday. I wish I had filled it up completely. I have not.

    2) I live in the U.S.

    3) My bank does not charge any fees for counting. But just in case they read this post and start a new policy to get a piece of my coin action, you’re still guessing the total amount in the jar.

    4) I don’t know the actual volume of the jar. Tonight I can post a picture with something beside it to give perspective.

    Good luck!

  209. hmmmmm… $314.51

  210. I guess $76.13. Thanks!

  211. I enjoy your posts immensely. Oh, and by the by is the ammount $19.47 ?
    Sure hope I win the shirt!

  212. $89.70

  213. 3.14159

  214. My guess is $213.67 for no particular reason.

  215. $86.25

  216. $89.69

  217. 265.25$

  218. $476.72

  219. $476.72

  220. $92.50!!

  221. $103.44

  222. $264.34

  223. $39.72

  224. 43.17

  225. $516.83

  226. $103.86 (I hated when people did that on Price is Right)

  227. $748.27.

    I’m an optimist.

  228. $128

  229. I’m going to guess $112.17

    Good luck to everyone.

  230. $202.75…assuming no atypical coins (Susan B Anthony, golden dollar, half dollars)

  231. $89.73. Looks penny-heavy.

    At Commerce Bank in the Philadelphia/NJ area, they have a free coin counting machine that doesn’t take a cut, like Coin Star. They also had a function that let you guess how much you had beforehand – if you got within 25 cents or so, you’d get a prize! Like, a free pen.

  232. $38.32

  233. $69.69

    hehe

  234. I’ll say… $666 XD

  235. hmm. . . $257.37

  236. Hmmm…
    Seems like my spyder cents is telling me…
    $37.36

  237. $108.78 but if you take it to a coin star they’ll take a percentage (but I don’t know how much…).

  238. $93.43. No one else bother, I know.

  239. $129.72

  240. $57.29

  241. $62.16

  242. $67.51

  243. $104.64

  244. $236 ish….

  245. $87

  246. $652.78

  247. $50.01

  248. I’ll guess $148.95

  249. $134.89

  250. umm….
    $112.00 and some lint

  251. $297.64

  252. 287.32

  253. I’m going with $82.48

  254. $127.63

  255. $123.45 Looks close, and might as well go with the nice numbers.

  256. $523.12

  257. $103.46

  258. $51.73

  259. $218.32

  260. I say 73.46

  261. $44.40

  262. $86.46!

  263. $91.12

  264. 173.50

  265. $51.05

  266. $123.52

  267. 57.63

  268. $162.12

  269. $155.23

  270. $27.59

  271. $37.43

  272. looks closer to $666.66 to me. It’s surprizing how much that volume of change is worth. I emptied a quart jar and counted over $300.

  273. $79.52

  274. My guess is $176.89

  275. $132.52

  276. $376.50

  277. $143.57

  278. $138.10

  279. 48.35

  280. $74.75

  281. 48.35

  282. I love this magazine! Could there possibly be $52.67?

  283. If it’s as full as the picture, I’m going to say $256.89….

  284. 95.79

  285. $77.72

  286. I’m going with $23.80 — ‘cuz I’ll bet you kept more quarters out. (I do).

  287. $29.78

  288. 67.34

  289. $112.56

  290. $142.44

  291. $76

  292. $162.13

  293. I’m gonna guess about……..$37.04

  294. $95.37

  295. 76.82

  296. 250.02

  297. $205.12

  298. $168.47

  299. $157.27

  300. $97.45 is my guess

  301. Wow, I’m guesser number 295. I didn’ look through all the guesses so I hope no one else picked $256.13.

  302. 61.52

  303. $43.34

  304. $358.72

  305. After seeing the comparison photos, I think I’ll change my guess.

    New guess: $198.43

  306. $67.78

  307. A few people left guesses on my own website. Wanted to make sure they were counted:

    1. judychrz says:
    June 15th, 2007 at 11:27 am e

    76.82

    2. Kent says:
    June 15th, 2007 at 12:39 pm e

    I think there is $98.67 and a Canadian dime or two

    3. rudie says:
    June 15th, 2007 at 6:01 pm e

    I think it’s at most 30 bucks…

    4. Adam says:
    June 16th, 2007 at 6:40 am e

    $83.27

    5. Leejay says:
    June 16th, 2007 at 9:17 am e

    How much did the dog guess?
    I guess $19.66.

  308. $83.83

  309. I guess $47.88! You should consider taking Bob Barkers place on the price is right!!

  310. $12.73

  311. $187.00 … and change.

  312. $84.62

    My wife’s jar never seems to get that full because my wife doesn’t count it, so I can buy lunch out occasionally =)

  313. I’m a gonna guess $678.90

  314. total = $428.62

  315. $210.07 (wish me luck!!!!)

  316. $215.78

  317. Thanks for your guesses. We’re closing comments and will announce the winner on Monday morning. Good luck!