
YOU WILL NEED
1 career that places you in frequent contact with tropical islands
1 unhappy superior
Fresh water
Ingenuity
Step 1: Royally Tick Off Your Boss
Like Christopher Columbus
The so-called discoverer of America was down on his luck by the time he’d made his fourth trip to the New World in 1502. He’d never found the vast quantities of gold needed to repay his investors (i.e. the Spanish Royal Court) and, as if to add insult to injury, he managed to get caught in a hurricane that sunk his boats and stranded him and 120 crewmen on the coast of what is now Jamaica. In fact, his crew was only 150 miles away from the Spanish fort on the island of Hispaniola but, because of that whole not-paying-back-Royal-loans thing, nobody came looking for them. Two crewmen even risked their lives to successfully paddle a canoe to Hispaniola, but instead of receiving help, they were given prison sentences! Meanwhile, the Governor of Hispaniola sent a messenger (by boat) to Jamaica to inform Columbus that no boat could be spared to rescue him. Talk about catty. All told, Columbus was marooned on Jamaica for almost a year before his imprisoned crewmen were released and managed to charter a ship to rescue their captain.
Like Alexander Selkirk
Of course, getting marooned has worked out better for some. Take the Scottish privateer Alexander Selkirk, for example, who got in a fight with his captain over some routine ship repair back in 1704. Selkirk, the second-in-command and ship’s navigator, thought the repairs needed to be made before the boat took off on another raid. The captain disagreed, so Selkirk cleverly announced that he’d rather stay on the deserted island where they’d anchored than get back on an unsafe ship. Unfortunately, he chose to end this speech with a Jerry Magiure-esque “Who’s comin’ with me?”…and nobody stood up. Worse, the captain then decided to take Selkirk at his word and literally left him, marooned, on the island. Selkirk ended up living there alone for more than four years, but it wasn’t all bad. The island had been the location of a failed Spanish colony, which had left behind feral goats and a and a veritable all-you-can-eat salad bar of semi-wild produce, including oats, plums, pumpkins, radishes, figs, and parsnips. There were even cats, which Selkirk tamed by the truckload, eventually sharing his cozy hut, cat-lady like, with more than a dozen. Frankly, it was a better life than you’d find on board a boat. In fact, when a British ship showed up to rescue Selkirk in 1709, he declared their worm-eaten biscuits and salted beef to be inedible. Instead, he invited the crew up to the hut for a healthy, home-cooked meal, simultaneously awing them with his kitchen skills and saving most of them from dying of scurvy. Selkirk’s ability to turn lemons into lemon soufflés so impressed his countrymen that his story was later fictionalized into a rather famous novel—Robinson Crusoe.
Enough! A DESERT island supports very little of the above mentioned possibilities. A desert island is something one fool passed on to other fools to repeat again and now we’re left with another “whole ‘nother” in common but mistaken use. I’d expect more from Flossers, c’mon already! Now, a DESERTED island, one free from human habitation rather than bereft of rainfall, that’s something worth discussion, that’s something folks can write stories about.
posted by John on 7-10-2007 at 12:03 pm
Bravo John.
posted by Ed on 7-10-2007 at 1:28 pm
Sorry, John..I read it and thought (in passing) the same thing but intellectual laziness swept over me…
At least one of us had the fortitude to point out the error. :)
posted by Ed Hands on 7-10-2007 at 1:34 pm
BUT THEN…in a robust show of google saaviness…I found this…
“A deserted island (also known as a ‘desert island’) is simply any uninhabited island: the word “desert” in this context is an adjective meaning “desolate and sparsely occupied or unoccupied,” and does not imply arid desert climate.[1] Such islands are commonly invoked in metaphor, literature, and the popular imagination.”
Wikipedia to the rescue….
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uninhabited_island
posted by Ed Hands on 7-10-2007 at 1:38 pm
I think the phrase “desert island” has cemented itself rather well in common language to mean “an uninhabited locale surrounded by water”. I have a hard time believing that John didn’t understand what was meant.
I better start being nicer to my boss, just in case.
posted by Bill T. on 7-10-2007 at 2:02 pm
Christ, John – chill out! Take your crap elsewhere, or just enjoy the articles.
posted by Nerdfury on 7-13-2007 at 2:20 am
How about stranding on a dessert island? Yummy!
posted by robin on 9-23-2008 at 7:09 am
How can one inhabit an uninhabited island? It’s a paradigm, with a meaning not restricted by one or two modifiers. It’s a literary construct we’ve all dreamed of visiting, once upon a time.
posted by Tom on 9-23-2008 at 9:11 am
You doubters must not have a good recipe for feral goat.
You should be watching Man v Wild and get all the tips you need.
posted by bucsfan on 9-23-2008 at 3:26 pm
Damn Interesting did an article about Alexander Selkirk a while back (click on my name for the link), which had a lot more details. Turns out he was a bit of a jerk and pissed the captain off, which was a major contributing factor in his being left behind. Also, turns out he and the goats were more than “just friends”.
posted by Steve on 9-23-2008 at 11:55 pm
Oops, forgot to include the link.
posted by Steve on 9-23-2008 at 11:58 pm