3 Big Cheeses in American Politics (and the Commotion They Caused)


Ed note: This week we're proud to have cheese expert and historian David Clark guest blogging with us. Today, he's reporting on three huge cheeses gifted to America's elected leaders, and the ruckuses they caused. Enjoy!

1. Thomas Jefferson and the Mammoth of Cheshire

When Thomas Jefferson became president in 1801, the people of Cheshire, Massachusetts, got very excited. As a community of Republican Baptists in a region dominated by Federalist Congregationalists, they had suffered their share of legal discrimination; and they believed that Jefferson would enforce a more decisive split between church and state, promoting the cause of religious liberty and bettering the lot of Cheshire.

So what did the good people of Cheshire do in the heat of enthusiasm? They crafted a 1235 pound cheese to bestow on the new president -- a token of their trust and admiration. Town elder John Leland, an eccentric and energetic activist, spearheaded the effort. A massive press was constructed, and on a designated day in July it was ceremoniously filled with curd from all the milk of all the town's cows. (All the cows except, of course, those tainted beasts owned by Federalists: Leland and company wanted to ensure the political purity of their gift.) At last the nascent cheese was dedicated, a hymn was sung; and after a period of pressing and curing, the Mammoth Cheshire Cheese was inscribed with a Jeffersonian inscription on its rind: "Rebellion to tyrants is obedience to God." Soon after, it began a month-long journey to the White House.

The traveling cheese sparked plenty of commotion and ballyhoo on its way. Crowds gathered to watch the "Ultra-Democratic, Anti-Federalist Cheese of Cheshire" pass; newspapers roared with endorsements or ridicule. Then on New Year's Day, 1802, Leland and his monster cheese finally reached Washington, where Jefferson graciously accepted the honor (although he later insisted on paying $200 for the gift).

In his speech for the occasion, the eloquent Founder said, "I shall cause this auspicious event to be placed upon the archives of the nation, while I shall ever esteem this occasion as one of the happiest in my history." Then they cut the cheese with pomp and fanfare, and the snacking began. Reports vary, but it would appear that White House inhabitants were still munching on Cheshire cheese for anywhere from six months to three years.

2. Old Hickory's Farewell Cheese Feast

The Mammoth of Cheshire was impressive, even intimidating, but not the last word on giant political cheeses. Before long an even larger cheese stormed Capital Hill. In 1835, a New York farmer decided to display his affection for President Andrew Jackson by sending a 1400 lb cheese to the White House.

jackson cheese.png
jackson cheese.png /

3. The Cheese (and Cider) that Caused a Riot

Smaller cheeses can cause big fiascos, too. Mrs. Longley of Maine probably didn't anticipate any trouble when she gifted a cheese weighing several hundred pounds to Governor John Fairfield, whom she greatly admired, in 1840. And Fairfield certainly meant well when he offered the cheese to his state's House of Representatives, for a bit of refreshment and a break from the serious business of governing.

It's up for debate whether Col. John Otis meant well when he presented a barrel of hard cider to go with Mrs. Longley's cheese. There's no doubt, however, that the "roguish wag" who secretly spiked Otis' cider with brandy had anything but innocent intentions. He slipped in so much booze that Maine's legislative branch quickly unwound. When the Speaker attempted to resume business, a crowd of (unwittingly) intoxicated lawmakers clamored for the floor. None would yield; those not on their feet egged the contenders on; and the Speaker became hoarse shouting into the bedlam. Nothing could be done. The combined force of cheese and spiked cider was too much for Republican government. So the Speaker moved to adjourn the House, only to be shouted down by a thunderous chorus of Nays. Helpless and discouraged, the Speaker sighed and washed his hands of it. He adjourned anyway, rose from his seat and left the mayhem to itself.