5 Creative Recipes That Use Canned Pumpkin and Pumpkin Pie Filling
This post originally appeared on Salon by Ashlie D. Stevens.
Compared to last autumn, it seems as though the pace is picking up again, for better or for worse. Kids are back in school, folks are returning to the office, and social calendars are filling up in advance of the holidays. That may leave many people, myself included, feeling a little strapped for time when it comes to cooking filling, flavorful meals.
That's where a duo of secret ingredients comes into play: canned pumpkin pie filling and straight canned pumpkin.
Canned pumpkin is exactly what it sounds like—the canned flesh of a baked and pureed roasting pumpkin with no seasoning, which makes it perfect for savory applications like pasta and hot sauces. Pumpkin pie filling, however, is sweetened and seasoned with warm baking spices, which provides a seasonal lift to baked goods and sweet treats like breakfast bread and cheesecakes.
Here are five of our favorite recipes that use canned pumpkin and pumpkin pie filling:
1. Pumpkin Spice Breakfast Bread
If you mastered a banana bread recipe during the pandemic, it's time to give those skills a seasonal update. Whereas banana bread takes on its signature moistness and almost caramelized sugar flavor from the use of overripe bananas, pumpkin spice breakfast bread uses pumpkin pie filling. Bonus: Pumpkin pie filling, as opposed to straight canned pumpkin, is already seasoned with pumpkin spice—a mixture of cinnamon, ginger, and nutmeg—which takes the guesswork out of seasoning. Find the full recipe here.
2. Smoky Pumpkin Hot Sauce
This hot sauce—which was featured on Salon's weekly condiment column “Saucy”—takes the best flavors of fall and bottles them up. Start by tossing a small roasting pumpkin in the oven. Once it's tender, blitz it with apple cider vinegar, apple juice, maple syrup, and spices. To save time, you can also use canned pumpkin.
The combination of fresh peppers (like red cayenne) and dried peppers (like chipotle peppers and chile de arbol) gives the resulting hot sauce an approachable, smoky spice. It's perfect with breakfast burritos loaded with autumnal vegetables like bitter greens and butternut squash. Find the full recipe here.
3. Creamy Pumpkin Sage Pasta Sauce
Canned pumpkin once again saves the day in this cheap and easy weeknight dinner. Use it as the base of a cozy pasta sauce, which thanks to the use of heavy cream or oat milk, is flavorful, creamy, and feels like fall in a bowl. The recipe is also easy to modify and veganize; some of my favorite add-ins include hot Italian sausage, crispy pan-fried mushrooms, and roasted vegetables. Find the full recipe here.
4. Luxurious Pumpkin Cheesecake
As Kelly Fields (author of The Good Book of Southern Baking) wrote, this recipe is “yet another result of my dislike of pumpkin pie.” Canned pumpkin whipped with cream cheese, espresso powder (a beloved ingredient here at Salon Food), and brown sugar are folded into a simple gingersnap crust. The resulting pumpkin cheesecake introduces an unexpected flavor combination—pumpkin and espresso—that goes together as beautifully as the classic duo of chocolate and peanut butter. Find the full recipe here.
5. Decadent PSL Milkshake
Alright, this is one of those recipes where I'm just going to need you to trust me. At least where I live, fall weather can be capricious. We still have plenty of 80°F days through late October. On days when it's just too hot for a seasonal coffee drink, pull out the blender and make this PSL milkshake made with vanilla ice cream, pumpkin spice, and cream. If you want to go more of a pumpkin pie route, feel free to add in 3 teaspoons of canned pumpkin pie filling, as well. Find the full recipe here.