Can You Solve This Old-Timey Riddle? #51

This riddle dates back to 1875—can you figure out the answer?
Can you figure it out?
Can you figure it out? | MirageC/Moment/Getty Images

Conundrums New and Old was an anonymous collection of short puzzles and riddles published in the U.S. in 1875. Like a lot riddle books from that time, many of the puzzles in this collection were punning back-and-forths rather than straightforward lateral-thinking games (a “lame dog” is like a mountainside because it is a “slow pup,” apparently). But amid the quips and jokes were more than a few genuinely tricky tests of mental agility, including the puzzle below. Can you work it out?

Take Our Latest Quizzes: