With fall in full swing, it’s officially time to stock up on your favorite autumn-inspired decorations. This year, take your love of pumpkin to the next level and think beyond the basic PSL. From nourishing body butter and hydrating lip balm to soy candles and coffee, here are 15 of the best pumpkin products that will surely become your next guilty pleasure.

1. Seasonal Syrup Set; $26

Uncommon Goods

This homemade syrup set features four fall-inspired flavors: vanilla maple, woodfired apple, golden age (featuring notes of salted honey and cardamom), and, of course, pumpkin spice. Use them in coffee, cocktails, or baked goods for an extra kick of October-y flavor. (Freshly baked apple pie enhanced with pumpkin pie sweetener? Yes, please.) Bonus: You’ll be supporting a woman-owned small business.

Buy it: Uncommon Goods

2. Pumpkin Soy Candle; $27

Lorenzen Candle Co/Amazon

Featuring sweet notes of sugar, butter, pumpkin, and other comforting spices, this all-natural soy candle smells so good you can (almost) taste it. It also contains essential oils like cinnamon leaf and nutmeg. Each hand-poured candle is crafted with love in Missouri. Its mason jar holder adds a shabby chic touch to any table, counter, or dresser.

Buy it: Amazon

3. Jordan's Sugar-Free Pumpkin Spice Coffee Syrup; $9

Jordan's/Amazon

Make your own PSL right at home with this pumpkin spice-flavored coffee syrup from Jordan's. This calorie-free flavor enhancer is a perfect addition to your coffee all year long.

Buy it: Amazon

4. Spiced Pumpkin Cider Whipped Body Butter; $18

Bath & Body Works/Amazon

Beauty junkies and fall fanatics alike can appreciate this spiced pumpkin cider whipped body butter by Bath & Body Works. This nourishing formula is packed with pure honey, shea butter, and coconut oil, all of which can help to hydrate and moisturize dry skin.

Buy it: Amazon

5. Pumpkin Face Mask; $10

JoeBash/RedBubble

This ultra-soft jack-o'-lantern face mask is especially fitting for fall—and, more specifically, Halloween, which is fast approaching. Plus, it’s machine-washable and offers a snug-yet-comfy fit, thanks to its polyester and spandex fabric blend. Choose from two sizes: kids and adults.

Buy it: RedBubble

6. Fragrance Oil Set; $17

P&J Trading/Amazon

This six-piece set from P&J Trading Company—which features fragrance oils inspired by apple cider, cinnamon, pumpkin pie, coffee cake, gingerbread, and harvest spice, respectively—smells like autumn in a box. Use them as soap bases, candle waves, perfumes, incense, or even in homemade cleaning products.

Buy it: Amazon

7. Pumpkin Chai Fragrance Diffuser; $53

Nest/Amazon

This pumpkin chai fragrance diffuser from Nest Candles is infused with a blend of masala chai, cardamom, pumpkin, ginger, and cinnamon. The set includes several “scent sticks,” which are pre-infused with the fragrance oil and designed to release a powerful (yet not overwhelmingly strong) aroma. Simply add the sticks to the accompanying sleek silver vessel and sniff away.

Buy it: Amazon

8. Burt's Bees Pumpkin Spice Lip Balm; $12

Burt's Bees/Amazon

Lip balm just became even more addictive. Not only does this pumpkin spice-flavored lip balm from Burt’s Bees smell amazing, but it’s also formulated to keep your pout moisturized all season long. (Bonus: It also helps to relieve pain and itching from cold sores.)

Buy it: Amazon

9. Jell-O Pumpkin Spice Flavor Instant Pudding and Pie Filling; $13

Jell-O/Amazon

Pumpkin pie is a staple throughout the fall, and this limited-release pumpkin spice Jell-O pudding could be the perfect filler if you’re looking for a quick way to make this dessert at home. Each box contains four packets, so that you can make up to 16 servings, and the pudding itself is free of high-fructose corn syrup and artificial sweeteners.

Buy it: Amazon

10. Glass Pumpkin; $45

Luke Adams Glass Store/Amazon

These 5-inch miniature glass pumpkins make the ideal fall accessory and add an adorable seasonal touch to any fireplace mantle, coffee table, or shelf (it also makes a great centerpiece for socially distanced dinners). Each is handcrafted in Massachusetts, and you can choose from 11 different colors, ranging from electric blue to blazing orange.

Buy it: Amazon

11. Pumpkin Spice Coffee; $11

Paramount Coffee/Amazon

Save money on Starbucks or Dunkin and brew your own pumpkin spice-flavored coffee right at home. This ground coffee from Paramount Coffee definitely hits the spot and can be enjoyed all year long. (Just be sure to store it in a cool and dry place away from direct sunlight.) Fun fact: The packaging features quotes taken from the love letters between John and Abigail Adams.

Buy it: Amazon

12. Pumpkin Mug; $15

Tstars/Amazon

This 11-ounce jack-o'-lantern mug is the perfect ode to your favorite spooky holiday. Use it for hot cocoa, pumpkin spice lattes, herbal teas, or even hot toddies. This ceramic mug is also dishwasher safe, microwave friendly, and ideal for long-lasting use.

Buy it: Amazon

13. Pepperidge Farm Pumpkin Cheesecake Cookies; $9

Pepperidge Farm/Amazon

Made with gooey chunks of pumpkin cheesecake, these limited-edition cookies from Pepperidge Farm deliver an autumnal spin on your favorite snack. Each bag has about nine servings, so you might want to get more than one if you have a household full of pumpkin spice-lovers.

Buy it:Amazon

14. Pumpkin Spice Cheerios; $16

Cherrios/Amazon

Start your day off right with a bowl of pumpkin spice Cheerios. This limited-edition breakfast is gluten-free and is sweetened with other fall-friendly spices like cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves.

Buy it: Amazon

15. Pumpkin Chai Poo-Pourri; $10

Poo-Pourri/Amazon

When you know you’ve got to go but you want to keep your business discreet, Poo-Pourri could be a great option. This pumpkin chai-scented spray is available in a two-ounce bottle and is good for up to 100 uses, according to the brand.

Buy it: Amazon

Sign Up Today: Get exclusive deals, product news, reviews, and more with the Mental Floss Smart Shopping newsletter!