9 Horror Sequels That Were Unexpectedly Brilliant

Sometimes a horror sequel turns out to be even better than the original, even in ways that the director didn’t necessarily intend to. Riding on an idea or franchise, good sequels get the opportunity to experiment and go bolder by doing things differently.

The idea of a horror sequel often gets a bad rap. More often than not, it can be a cash-grab or an unnecessary rehashing of familiar scares until the creative well runs dry. Yet, sometimes, they deliver in surprising ways. Here are some horror sequels that were accidentally brilliant because they didn’t aim to be groundbreaking, yet they ended up actually being as good—or better—than the first.

1. Evil Dead 2 (1987)
2. 10 Cloverfield Lane (2016)
3. Ouija: Origin of Evil (2016)
4. Annabelle: Creation (2017)
5. Pearl (2022)
6. Terrifier 2 (2022)
7. Dawn of the Dead (1978)
8. Doctor Sleep (2019)
9. Aliens (1986)

Evil Dead 2 (1987)

The sequel to The Evil Dead (1981) came out in 1987, directed by Sam Raimi and starring Bruce Campbell. The budget was modest (about $3.5 million), but Raimi turned it into something wild with more gore, more slapstick, and more style. 

What makes it brilliant is how it merged horror with dark comedy. Campbell’s Ash Williams is a more confident character here, and the film leans into its own absurdity. The original Evil Dead had its charm, but Evil Dead 2 refined it into something more weird and much more fun. 

10 Cloverfield Lane (2016)

10 Cloverfield Lane wasn’t even supposed to be a sequel to Cloverfield at first. It began as a script called The Cellar, and then the producers decided to tie it loosely to the Cloverfield universe. The result is a confined-bunker thriller with brilliant performances by Mary Elizabeth Winstead and John Goodman. 

The first movie was chaotic with its found-footage style, but this sequel (or spiritual sequel) went in a very unique direction. The actors and some of the crew didn’t even know it was a Cloverfield movie until late in production, when the ending was changed to tie into the original.

Ouija: Origin of Evil (2016)

The first Ouija movie was panned, but the follow-up took a different path. Directed by Mike Flanagan and set in 1967, it feels like a period haunted-house film. The realistic set design and the vintage camera-feel touches are just some of the aspects that made this movie much better than its predecessor. 

The original Ouija was more jump-scare oriented, but this one builds upon great atmosphere, uses the board game concept smartly, and feels less like a cash-grab and more like a genuine sequel that wanted to get it right. 

Annabelle: Creation (2017)

The first Annabelle, a spin-off from the Conjuring series, was okay but didn’t blow minds. Enter the prequel, Annabelle: Creation, directed by David F. Sandberg. He wanted to make something more like old-school horror. It’s a period piece that’s slightly different. 

The film sets up the doll’s origin in 1955. It uses orphans in a creepy house, and plays the doll not as a jump-scare puppet but as creeping dread. It changed the tone as well. The first film had a lot of cheap frights, but this one slowed down to build the mood and elevated the story. 

Pearl (2022)

Pearl is a prequel to X (2022) by Ti West, but still a follow-up in a lot of ways. The film was shot right after X and stars Mia Goth in the lead. What makes it different and better is the big change in time period and aesthetics. It’s set in 1918 and uses a Technicolor-inspired palette.

The original X was a gritty slasher that paid homage to various originators of the genre, but Pearl is stylish, unsettling, and character-driven, all while paying homage to a different time period of movies.

You May Also Like:

Add Mental Floss as a preferred news source!

Terrifier 2 (2022)

The first Terrifier was a fun little indie slasher that became popular for its lead, Art the Clown, and its extreme gore. But Terrifier 2 turned that into a full-on cinematic event with a bigger budget and noticeably better production value. 

Director Damien Leone got a higher budget this time compared to just $35,000 for the first, and you can see it all on-screen with bigger sets, even better practical effects, and more ambitious storytelling. Even with all that, it didn’t lose its grindhouse energy, thankfully. Leone refused to tone anything down.

Dawn of the Dead (1978)

George A. Romero’s Dawn of the Dead is one of those sequels that didn’t just improve on the first but also practically redefined zombie cinema. The original, Night of the Living Dead (1968), was raw and black-and-white. 10 years later, Romero came back with color, satire, and a much bigger vision. 

The film takes place mostly inside a shopping mall, which sounds small on paper, but it became a clever critique of consumerism—people literally turning into zombies in a mall. The makeup effects by Tom Savini were groundbreaking at the time. And the mix of horror, humor, and social commentary gave it depth. Even Dario Argento, the Italian horror master, helped edit and score parts of the European version.

Doctor Sleep (2019)

Mike Flanagan had one of the toughest jobs ever with Doctor Sleep—make a follow-up to The Shining. How do you even attempt that? The movie, based on Stephen King’s 2013 novel, picks up decades later with a grown-up Danny Torrance (played by Ewan McGregor). The story focused on trauma, addiction, and redemption. 

Flanagan had to balance two worlds—both King’s book and Stanley Kubrick’s 1980 film—and he pulled it off by blending both. The final act revisits the Overlook Hotel, recreated perfectly down to the carpet pattern and lighting. Doctor Sleep wasn’t a massive box office hit, but fans and critics later realized how strong it really is. It feels like a spiritual sequel done right.

Aliens (1986)

If Alien was a haunted house movie in space, Aliens turned it into a full-blown war film. James Cameron took Ridley Scott’s slow-burning horror masterpiece and added great adrenaline and action. It’s set 57 years after the first movie, and Sigourney Weaver returns as Ellen Ripley.

The shift in tone could’ve gone wrong in so many ways, but Cameron’s background with The Terminator helped him make action feel terrifying, and lean more towards the horror and intensity. It’s rare for a sequel to stand equal with a classic, but Aliens did exactly that, and can easily be considered even better than the original.