Where Knowledge Junkies Get Their Fix
McAfee Secure sites help keep you safe from identity theft, credit card fraud, spyware, spam, viruses and online scams
David K. Israel
Suffer From Disposophobia?
These 7 Famous Hoarders Did

by David K. Israel - October 22, 2009 - 9:07 AM

Do you have trouble throwing stuff out? Afraid to let go of that old remote control for the broken TV you’ve got stored away in the basement just in case you might need it someday? You might be suffering from disposophobia, sometimes called pathological hoarding. Of course, there’s a big difference between needing to exorcise your clutter and hoarding, pack rat-style. Disposophobia is a serious form of OCD, and one not to be taken lightly, as the following seven people prove.

1. & 2. Homer and Langley Collyer

Collyer5The Collyer brothers have been the subjects of movies, plays and a recent novel by E.L. Doctorow. With American roots tracing back to the days of the Mayflower, Homer and Langley Collyer were well-off members of Manhattan’s elite. After their parents’ death in the 1920s, the brothers withdrew from society and divided their time between their family’s Manhattan and Harlem brownstones. Appropriately enough, thanks to Homer (who was also crippled and blind) and his brother Langley, disposophobia is also sometimes referred to as ‘Collyer brothers syndrome.’

Why? Because as the brothers became more and more reclusive, rumors began circulating that the houses were filled with riches and the brothers set booby traps to protect their valuables. Then, in 1947, a neighbor called police complaining of a pungent odor. Inside the Harlem brownstone police found Homer Collyer dead. His corpse was amid tons of junk, including an early X-ray machine, the jawbone of a horse and bundles upon bundles of old newspapers.

His brother Langley was nowhere to be found, and a nationwide manhunt was conducted. Weeks later, when half the brownstone had been cleared of 180 tons of junk, a worker discovered Langley’s decomposed corpse buried beneath a stack newspapers. He had been dead for weeks and rats had eaten most of his body. It was ultimately determined that Homer died of starvation when Langley, who fed his crippled, blind brother, was crushed to death under—what else?—a bunch of junk.

3. & 4. The women of Grey Gardens

little-edie-grey-gardensIn the early 1970s, two women related to Jackie Onassis were the subjects of the critically acclaimed documentary, Grey Gardens, about eccentric behavior. The women, Edith Bouvier Beale and her mother, Edith Ewing Bouvier, were former New York socialites who spent their days holed up in a decrepit East Hampton mansion.

When the Suffolk County Board of Health raided their house, they found piles of garbage amid human and animal waste. It was said that only three of the mansion’s 28 rooms were used, while the others were occupied by hundreds of cats, possums and raccoons.

When word of the deplorable conditions got to Jackie-O, she and her then-husband Aristotle Onassis paid $32,000 to clean the house, install a new furnace and plumbing system, and cart away 1,000 bags of garbage. When Grey Gardens filmmakers Albert and David Maysles began to shoot there in 1973, the mansion was so infested with fleas that they had to wear flea collars around their ankles.

5. Edmund Trebus

trebusTV viewers all over the UK knew compulsive hoarder Edmund Trebus for his eccentric habits and snarky English temper. Featured on the 1999 television documentary A Life of Grime, Trebus would often tell friends and neighbors to “stick it up your chuffer!” especially when they complained about the odor emanating from his house. The majority of his household junk was acquired from his neighbors’ trash, and Trebus went to great lengths to collect any material related to his favorite musician, Elvis Presley. He had an expansive Elvis collection that included most of the King’s original records. But it was the flotsam and jetsam that took up most of his five-bedroom Victorian villa at Crouch End in north London: window frames, motorbikes, scaffolding poles, tree-trunks, For Sale signs (complete with posts), fridge-freezers, even a mortuary table.

The smell his neighbors complained about was a result of the bags of rotting vegetables (mostly grown in his own garden!) piled from floor to ceiling in every room. At the time of his death, Trebus’s North London home was so stuffed with junk that he was living in a small area on the floor.

6. Ida Mayfield Wood

Picture 5In the late 19th century, all of New York’s high society knew Ida Mayfield. Her charm and beauty attracted many suitors and Ida eventually married Benjamin Wood, publisher of the New York Daily News. But the couple’s marriage was an unhappy one and Benjamin fathered a child by another woman.

To make up for his womanizing, Benjamin would give his wife large sums of money to deposit into her own savings account. By the time of Benjamin’s death in 1900, Ida was a very wealthy and powerful woman. The influential pages of the New York Daily News were now under her control. But after the financial panic of 1907, Ida grew increasingly paranoid about her finances and withdrew from society.

She lived in squalor in a couple of rooms at New York’s Herald Square Hotel and never went outside. By the time of her death in 1932, Ida had hoarded nearly $1 million in cash, stuffed in pots and pans inside the hotel room. Among other valuables found inside were a diamond necklace hidden in a Cracker Jack box. Ida was even found to have $10,000 in cash sealed around her waist.

7. Bettina Grossman

Picture 4New York’s famed Chelsea Hotel, the place everyone from Mark Twain to Janis Joplin once called home, was also home to an unknown artist by the name of Bettina Grossman. Bettina had been living in the Chelsea as one of its artists-in-residence for 30 years and had amassed an entire lifetime of artwork. The fruits of Bettina’s labor lay stashed away in hundreds of boxes inside her tiny two-room apartment.

When filmmaker Sam Bassett, another artist-in-residence at the Chelsea, discovered Ms. Grossman, she was literally sleeping on a deck chair in the hallway. Bassett became inspired by Bettina’s artwork and eventually convinced her to display her various collages and mixed media portraits. He even helped her build shelves to organize it all. Bettina agreed, and Bassett’s 2007 documentary, Bettina, chronicles the eccentric artist’s long road to personal recovery.

Last year, Ms. Grossman fell and broke her hip, and is now living a Brooklyn nursing home. Still, her artwork is never far behind. She’s brought a few boxes of her work with her to the home.

More from mental_floss

11 Things Wal-Mart Has Banned
*
4 of History’s Greatest Hoaxes
*
Why Does Bottled Water Have An Expiration Date?
*
19 Unusual Sports Injuries (Including ‘Too Much GameBoy’)
*
A Brief History of Gummy Bears
*
The Origins of 6 Casino Favorites
*
The Mendoza Line and Other Sports Terms Named for People
*
31 Unbelievable High School Mascots

twitterbanner.jpg

August-Top9

tshirtsubad_static-11.jpg

Comments (16)
  1. You must have the wrong century in your bit about Ida Mayfield Wood. You mention 1900 and 1907, so I assume you really meant to say the late *19th* century.

  2. Read it again, Rick.

  3. Also on the Ida Mayfield Wood one – where is that photo from? I assume they didn’t leave the trash collecting in the room for years until they developed color photography…

  4. I saw an episode of A&E’s Hoarders that had to be the perfect storm of that disorder. The husband was a hoarder and the wife was a compulsive shopper. Yikes.

  5. So, all that money and too paranoid about losing it to enjoy it, in some cases.

  6. Who wants a Clean House?

  7. is it just me, or does there seem to be a connection between hoarders and New York?

  8. I installed a stereo system at the brownstone of Huntington Hartford, the A&P heir. His bedroom was the same way, floor to ceiling newspapers and junk. He blew the entire fortune away.

  9. I have a childhood friend who is now a hoarder. His daughter is in the fourth grade, and he has kept every single piece of artwork, homework, tests, or simple notices she’s brought home from school through the years. Anybody who has kids will realize how utterly insane this is. There is no organization for this collection however. He also had 14 cats last I checked. I’ve noticed hoarding material objects tends to go hand in hand with animal hoarding. His mom is a hoarder as well. At one point in time she had at least 63 cats before the Humane Society stepped in.

  10. the 2000’s are the 21st century; the 19th century would be the 1800’s

  11. @melly,

    The first color photograph was taken in 1861. That doesn’t look like a hotel room to me, though, so it might just be a photo of a similar mess, rather than the original.

  12. Delta Burke of the Golden Girls was also a hoarder. She even had storage buildings she rented to store it in.

  13. Delta Burke was on Designing Women not Golden Girls.

  14. These people are all stuck on not throwing stuff out?? So weird.

  15. a person in my life could be next on the list – not famous, but infamous in her neighborhood for the mess. gets very upset if even an empty Coke can is thrown away. if she cleans her car of trash on the inside, once a year, she’s done her job. this is trash level with her windows and the trunk is jammed. garage sales are her fave. i showed her a pic of a woman who died in u.k. recently buried by her junk, and she didn’t even get it – she says, it’s my house, my car, i’ll live the way i want – and then feels rejected, because nobody else wants to sit on a bag of donuts, a bra, and/or a plate of uneaten food – she’s missing something upstairs – hey, maybe she’s searching!

  16. The Hoarders episode with the cats…that got to me. They found skeletons–GAH! I am a slob, but anytime I don’t feel like cleaning, I watch that show. It helps. LOL!

Comment

commenting policy