Claudia Kishi Creation or Fashionista Flop?

Now that we know there's a whole legion of _floss readers who grew up reading The Baby-sitters Club, we thought it was time to discuss the best part of the books: Claudia's funky—and frequently frightening—fashions. But today's non-fiction fashionistas could give Claud a run for her money—can you distinguish between the Claudia Kishi creations and descriptions of outfits worn by celebrities?

1 of 16
"For example, that day she was wearing a lacy white top over a solid white bodysuit, a black mini skirt with white polka dots on it, lacy white leggings, and red high-tops. Plus some really outrageous black-and-white jewelry."
Kishi Creation
Fashionista Flop
2 of 16
"Today she was wearing a bright pink t-shirt, a short red flouncy skirt, and underneath the skirt she had on black footless tights that she had rolled up to mid-calf."
Kishi Creation
Fashionista Flop
3 of 16
"Today, for example, she had stuck to two colors: black and white. Black bib overalls over a white turtleneck with a shiny black patent leather belt looped around her waist. Black suede ankle boots and white cotton socks. Long black hair swept off her face with giant white plastic barrettes."
Kishi Creation
Fashionista Flop
4 of 16
"Today she was wearing purple-and-white-striped tights, Doc Martens, a short black ruffly skirt, a purple cropped sweater with silver buttons, and a scrunchy black velvet hat decorated with purple and red velvet flowers."
Kishi Creation
Fashionista Flop
5 of 16
"First, she had on a white tank top with navy blue stars on it, and on top of it (the layered look) she had a sweatshirt with arrows and candy bars on it. Then she wore some wild purple jeans and a pair of black and pink sneakers. Her hair was loose but she had tied a strip of multicolored cloth around her head like a headband."
Kishi Creation
Fashionista Flop
6 of 16
"I was wearing a very short black skirt, an oversized white shirt with bright pink and turquoise designs on it, flat turquoise shoes with ankle straps, and a ton of jewelry."
Kishi Creation
Fashionista Flop
7 of 16
"She had really outdone herself today – dark blue sequined pants, a white dress shirt with a high collar that went up around her neck, a red jacket with big gold buttons that kind of made her look like she was the ringleader at a circus, some chunky gold necklaces and red patent leather shoes with three straps."
Kishi Creation
Fashionista Flop
8 of 16
"Today I had decided on a plain white sleeveless top, a black sweater and some really worn-looking denim shorts rolled up at the bottom. I had layered these with stirrup tights, then added black leather shoes and a grey scarf looped once around my neck."
Kishi Creation
Fashionista Flop
9 of 16
"For example, today I was wearing a blue and white-striped short-sleeved jumper, with vertical stripes on top and horizontal stripes on the bottom, a bunch of bracelets up each arm including this funky snakeskin patterned one, big round silver earrings I made myself, and white sandals with three straps."
Kishi Creation
Fashionista Flop
10 of 16
"A pink sundress with spaghetti straps and big blue buttons down the front. I tied a pink-and-blue scarf around my waist, added my snake bracelet and feather earrings, and finally put on these white sandals with long laces that you crisscross up your legs."
Kishi Creation
Fashionista Flop
11 of 16
"From the waist up, she looked like she was wearing a private school uniform - a black v-neck sweater with a collared white shirt and even a skinny black tie. But on the bottom she had on these dibbly-fresh animal print shorts, black tights and some low black boots. She was wearing big chunky bracelets on each wrist. She has this great hair that she is always doing different things with - little braids and side ponytails and stuff. Today, she had pulled it back from her face but styled the bangs so they kind of sat in a big curl on top of her head."
Kishi Creation
Fashionista Flop
12 of 16
"She had on this neon green tank top under a white oversized man's shirt and fuchsia pink stirrup pants. The shirt was rolled at the sleeves and belted with a colorful woven belt."
Kishi Creation
Fashionista Flop
13 of 16
"Today, she had on a plain black top with some faint circles printed on it. You might think this was boring, but she had paired it with black leggings with a white geometric pattern all over them. Then she put on some hot pink fingerless gloves, beaded bracelets and some tall white boots with black laces. She looked amazing."
Kishi Creation
Fashionista Flop
14 of 16
"I'd settled on a long white shirt under a green tapestry vest, green corduroy pants, and low boots."
Kishi Creation
Fashionista Flop
15 of 16
"Today, she was wearing a white, short sleeved blouse, tucked into loose, ballooney, navy blue satin shorts. Then she had on - get this - hot pink tights and silver shoes. On anyone else this color combo would look ridiculous, but she looked totally cool. She topped the look off with big coral-colored beads and a grey beret."
Kishi Creation
Fashionista Flop
16 of 16
"Today she was wearing a plain grey dress, but put a yellow leather jacket over it with matching yellow shoes on her feet that looked like bowling shoes."
Kishi Creation
Fashionista Flop